Payson AZ Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Homes For Sale

$999,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 6896937 MLS Seneca Pines SubDv. ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
Welcome to a rare offering of refined mountain living, where timeless charm meets unmatched versatility. This home is Airbnb-ready with a long rental history. Tucked beneath a canopy of towering pines on 1.54 private acres, this home is a sanctuary of sophistication and comfort, perfectly suited for a grand family retreat, luxury inn, or executive getaway. The stately main residence showcases four elegant master suites, each appointed with a private en-suite bath, cozy fireplace, and a personal balcony or patio for enjoying the tranquil forest setting. At the heart of the home lies a professional chef's kitchen, outfitted with rich granite countertops, premium stainless steel appliances, a Vulcan gas range, double ovens, and a generous walk-in pantry, crafted for both intimate meals and large-scale entertaining. A soaring great room invites gatherings with its open layout and warm ambiance, while the expansive upstairs game room offers space for recreation or relaxation. A private executive office with sweeping panoramic views overlooks a serene meadow frequented by elk and deer, blending productivity with nature's inspiration. The property also includes a 1,100 sq ft guest house, ideal for visiting family or guests. Outdoors, the experience continuesgather in the charming backyard gazebo, or unwind beneath the stars. Every detail has been thoughtfully crafted to embrace the beauty and peace of mountain living. Although secluded and serene, this exceptional estate is just a short stroll from shopping, dining, and entertainment, offering the perfect balance of privacy and convenience. A truly one-of-a-kind offering, luxury, lifestyle, and limitless potential await. Buyer to verify square footage and acreage.

2444 S Jan Lane, Pinetop

$1,100,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 6886140 MLS Country Club Ranchos SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Private Horse Ranch Retreat in the Heart of Payson, Arizona. Tucked away on 2.71 acres of pristine land, your new horse property is more than just a home -- it's a lifestyle. Your secluded slice of heaven is fully fenced, cross-fenced, and thoughtfully set up for both horses and cows. Whether you're a full-time rancher, hobby farmer, or outdoor lover looking for space to roam, this place has you covered. Set up new ranch home features a beautiful covered porch, four bedrooms, and 2.75 bathrooms, including a private guest suite setup perfect for multi-generational living, visitors, or a rental opportunity -- all under one roof. And not just any roof: your 50-year metal roof is designed to look like beautiful tile shingles, offering both durability and curb appeal. Your high quality, custom FCP barn is the envy of many! It is beautifully crafted and designed to make ranch life easy and accessible. You can pull a trailer of hay right inside and feed right off it. No more moving heavy bales over to the barn from hay storage. There's plenty of room to park a truck and trailer inside too! Either way, it's ready for your animals to move right in. And when you're done riding, enjoy time under the shade of all the beautiful trees on your property or gather fresh eggs from your chicken coop, or simply soak up the peaceful mountain air. Additional equestrian features include a classic shed row barn with individual run-outs, a round pen, and multiple sheds for feed, tools, and tack. You'll also find a 3-car garage and a 2-car garage  perfect for storing your truck, trailer, toys, or farm equipment. Bonus? There's an indoor dog kennel setup for puppies, sick dogs, or those that just need a cozy outdoor haven. This property offers true privacy, with few neighbors in sight  just you, the elk, deer, and abundant wildlife that wander through. Whether you're working the land or simply enjoying the quiet, it's a dream come true for anyone craving a rural escape with all the right amenities. Welcome home to Payson  where nature, freedom, and country living meet. Easy to see with a few hours advanced notice.

2404 W Palmer Drive, Payson

$85,000
6877446 MLS Portal Pine Creek Canyon 3 SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Top views from this elevated view homesite in Pine, AZ's prestigious Portal subdivision! Water meter is active on property. 0.39 acre lot offers a prime perch for your dream mountain home with stunning vistas of the Mogollon Rim. Improved with utilities to the lot, it's accessible via a paved street to a serene, perfectly oriented, cul-de-sac home-site in a beautiful neighborhood. A great escape, Pine's weather is ~20° cooler than the valley's summer heat, perfect for year-round enjoyment, tranquility, and outdoor fun--hiking and Verde River adventures await. Enjoy great shopping, dining, and welcoming people, all an easy drive--less than 2 hours from Phoenix via the scenic BeeLine Highway. A completed home design is yours with an acceptable offer. Seize this cool, inspiring retr Welcome message on the Portal 3 HOA website: Half way up the sunrise-lit side of Pine Creek Canyon is the residential community of Portal III. One hundred and ninety eight properties have unique blends of shady pine woods and breathtaking views. Milk Ranch Point, 1000 feet above Portal III across Pine Creek Canyon on the Mogollon Rim, dominates the view to the east. To the north, the canyon dwindles as the east and west walls converge. To the south, the canyon view opens wide for a distant view of the Mazatzal Mountains and Four Peaks, 75 miles away. To the west, Portal III abuts the Tonto National Forest and shares its wildlife. With a four season climate and lot plans that protect privacy, residents are led to outdoor living. Harmony of building and land is key, maximizing the natural environment. Each home is individually crafted to complement the natural setting of the land and reflect the woodsy settings. This community is less than two hours from Phoenix and Scottsdale for convenient weekend getaways. Situated between the quaint towns of Pine and Strawberry, it is just 15 miles north of Payson. - - - - - - -

132 N Knob Hill -- Unit 132, Pine

$650,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 6860825 MLS Elk Ridge SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Updated Payson Beauty with Views, Prime Location & Move-In Ready Peace of Mind! Why wait for the perfect mountain home when it is already here? Nestled in one of Payson's most sought-after communities, this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers the ideal combination of location, comfort, modern updates, and breathtaking scenery -- all just minutes from everyday conveniences. Imagine waking up to beautiful views and enjoying cool mountain mornings while living just moments from the hospital, shopping, schools, Green Valley Park, dining, and all the charm that makes Payson one of Arizona's favorite mountain escapes. At over 5,000 feet elevation, experience the enjoyment of four mild seasons and a lifestyle that feels peaceful, refreshing, and connected to nature. Inside, pride of ownership shines throughout. Thoughtfully updated and meticulously maintained, this move-in-ready home offers the peace of mind today's buyers are searching for. The beautifully remodeled kitchen (2022) serves as the heart of the home, featuring stylish finishes designed for both everyday living and entertaining. New flooring throughout much of the home creates a fresh, cohesive feel, while the inviting fireplace adds warmth and ambiance for cozy mountain evenings. Major improvements have already been completed for you, including a new roof (2023), exterior paint and lighting (2024), fencing (2021), updated irrigation system (2023), and numerous interior upgrades -- allowing you to simply move in and start enjoying life. Whether you are entertaining friends, relaxing after a day exploring Rim Country, or simply enjoying the views from home, this property offers the perfect blend of convenience, comfort, and mountain living. Homes in this desirable location with this level of updating and care do not come along often. Furnishings are negotiable, making this an even easier opportunity to begin enjoying your Payson lifestyle.

601 E Phoenix Street, Payson

$1,150,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 6858671 MLS Check Map SubDv. ACTIVE Status
The Diamond Point Masterpiece: Luxury, Privacy, and Space in Star Valley, AZ. Presenting a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity! For the first time ever, this magnificent 3,383 sq ft custom residence in the highly sought-after Diamond Point Shadows community is available. Meticulously cared for by its original owner, this home is the epitome of luxury, space, and functionality. Situated on a sprawling 2.49-acre estate, this rare property offers the unparalleled freedom of no HOA and the privacy you deserve. From the dedicated enthusiast's garage to the chef-grade kitchen and the versatile finished basement, every detail has been thoughtfully designed for an uncompromising lifestyle. ***Exceptional Acreage: Sprawling 2.49-acre lot with rare Horse Property *** NO HOA. ***Massive Garage Space: Impressive 4+ Car Heated Garage plus a dedicated RV Garage. ***Flexible Garage Layout: Includes a dedicated office space and an additional bedroom perfect for a guest suite or private workspace. ***Chef's Dream Kitchen: Two expansive islands for abundant workspace. Extra-large walk-in pantry. Top-of-the-line Viking appliances (4-burner stove, warming drawer, double oven). ***Expansive Great Room: Features vaulted ceilings, a cozy brick fireplace (pellet stove), and direct access to the outdoor entertaining area. ***Luxurious Main Suite: Thoughtfully designed split floor plan for ultimate privacy. Two generously sized walk-in closets. Spa-like ensuite with a dual vanity, large dual jetted tub, and spacious dual-headed walk-in shower. ***Oversized Guest Rooms: Each features its own thermostat for personalized comfort. ***Versatile Finished Basement: Huge space ideal for a media room, additional sleeping quarters, or a secure area (gun safe/workshop). ***Outdoor Entertaining: Backyard features a gazebo and built-in BBQ entertaining area. ***Peace of Mind and Modern Comfort New Roof and New A/C Unit recently installed. ***Whole-House Generac Generator ensures uninterrupted comfort and security. Embrace the freedom of space, the luxury of high-end finishes, and the tranquility of a premier location. This is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle waiting to be embraced. Don't miss your chance to own this Diamond Point Shadows gem!

889 E Dealers Choice Lane, Payson

$1,099,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 6854195 MLS Forest Trails Unit 2 SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Looking for your perfect escape from triple-digit summers? This modern mountain retreat in Overgaard sits at 6,600 feet elevation, where cool pines replace scorching pavement and the Mogollon Rim becomes your backyard. And getting here just got easier: the seller is offering private financing at 4% interest with 25% down, and is open to trading for a home in the Phoenix metro area. Two creative paths to ownership, one extraordinary destination. The unforgettable Mogollon Rim views steal the show in this modern mountain retreat, designed to bring nature to your doorstep, which is best experienced in person. Perched on a private, firewise corner lot, this south-facing stunner features expansive glass doors, multiple wood balconies, and sleek interior finishes including solid oak flooring, peacock slate bathrooms, and a premium LG kitchen with induction range. A full guest studio with private entry, kitchen, and bath offers flexible living for guests, multigenerational households, or even summer cooking. Step inside and you'll feel it immediately: this is not just a home... it's a retreat. A place to reset, reconnect, and unwind. South-facing windows frame an ever-changing panorama of the Mogollon Rim, with sunlight dancing through the trees and into the heart of the home. The open-concept great room flows seamlessly to outdoor decks perfect for sipping coffee at sunrise, sharing wine at sunset, or simply breathing in the fresh mountain air. Whether you're entertaining or savoring quiet solitude, nature is always in view. The main kitchen is as refined as it is functional, featuring granite counters, sleek cabinetry, and top-of-the-line LG appliances including an induction cooktop with air-fry feature. A second full kitchen on the lower level offers added convenience, doubling as a summer kitchen or a fully independent suite for long-term guests. Planning to age in place, accommodate varying mobility levels, or just enjoy an easier way to bring up your gear and groceries? The built-in elevator provides smooth access to the upper level -- perfect for second homeowners, multigenerational living, or those who simply prefer an effortless lifestyle. Bathrooms are elevated with spa-like slate and granite finishes, walk-in showers, river rock floors, upgraded fixtures, and fan timers. From the heated, epoxy-coated garage and programmable thermostats to the seamless rain gutters and leveler blinds, no detail was overlooked. A central vacuum system, 200-amp electric service, and electric water heaters with timers add to the home's quiet efficiency. Roof is composite with a lifetime manufacturer's guarantee. Outside, fire-resistant native landscaping blends beauty with safety, while a rounded driveway ensures ease of access year-round. Central A/C keeps you comfortable through every season. Whether you're seeking a high-end primary residence or a lock-and-leave second home, this one-of-a-kind property offers the lifestyle you've been dreaming about. Photos can't fully capture the calm. Drive through the neighborhood. Sit on the balcony. Feel what it's like to live above it all.

2943 E Lookout Lane, Overgaard

Start Your Search

All information should be verified by the recipient and none is guaranteed as accurate by ARMLS. Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Cabins in Payson for sale - Cabins for sale in Arizona - Cabins for sale on the river Payson, AZ

     

 

Payson Arizona Trail to home | Payson Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Real Estate

Search homes for sale in Payson AZ. Find your dream home with our extensive and complete listings, including a mortgage calculator.

The Payson area is a beautiful place to live for those who enjoy the great outdoors. There is plenty of both mountain scenery and desert landscapes to explore. The town itself has many unique shops, restaurants, and galleries. There are also plenty of outdoor activities that are available year-round, from skiing and snowshoeing in the winter months to horseback riding and hiking through the mountains in the warmer spring and summer months.

Payson AZ homes for sale near White Horse Lake offer residents access to all kinds of outdoor recreational activities with easy access to trails, fishing, boating, camping areas, and more.

Find your dream home

With thousands of listings, scottschulte.com is the best place to find your new home. Search homes by price, location, or the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Check out our mortgage calculator to see what you can afford!

Contact us for more info

We're always happy to help you find what you're looking for. Contact us today and we'll be in touch soon!

A Paradise for Outdoor Adventurers

Payson is nestled within the tall, fragrant Ponderosa Pines, and the nearby Tonto National Forest provides easy access to all kinds of outdoor recreation. Bird watching, hiking, horseback riding, hunting, mountain biking are just a few.

Fishing and kayaking are available at any of the nearby lakes, such as Bear Canyon Lake, Woods Canyon Lake, or the lakes at Green Valley Park. The area around Payson is also great for rock hounds. Very high-quality quartz crystals can be found, as well as agate, geodes, and onyx. You can also find fossils along State Route 87 and State Route 260 west of town.

Payson also has three golf courses and the Mazatzal Casino, operated by the Tonto Apache, on their reservation near the south end of town. To put it simply, Payson has all the fun activities you love. Likewise, it’s in the heart of Arizona puts you within a 2-hour drive of everything else this state has to offer.

Steeped in Western Heritage

The town was founded in 1882, and the annual “August Doin’s Rodeo” is the oldest continuous rodeo in the country, and has been held ever since 1884. The event kicks off with a parade down Main Street and features food, music and of course, a rodeo. In May, the Gary Hardt Memorial Rodeo takes place at the Multi-Purpose Event Center, across the road from the Tonto Apache Indian Reservation.

In addition to the rodeo, Payson set the stage for author Zane Grey’s many popular Western novels. Grey first passed through Payson in 1918, and eventually purchased 120-acres of Payson AZ real estate along Tonto Creek.

The town has quite a few art galleries specializing in Western art, and for those who love Old-Timey music, Payson hosts the annual Arizona State Championship Old-Time Fiddlers Contest in September.

Living in Payson is Cool!

Whether you’re young or retired, Payson offers a lot to anyone who savors the small-town lifestyle. Payson AZ real estate is appreciating fast, averaging 7% year over year. That means Homes for sale in Payson may be a good investment in the years to come. If you’ve been thinking about moving to Payson, now is the time to buy a home here.

The lifestyle is both slower and more active than a big city like Phoenix, and the weather is nicer. If you savor hiking, biking, and fishing under the pines, consider looking into homes for sale in Payson.