Payson AZ Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Homes For Sale

$645,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 6922805 MLS Seneca Pines SubDv. ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT Status
950 E Osprey Lane, Pinetop, AZ 85935 | Seneca Pines Inspection is complete and all repairs have been finished--this home is ready for an effortless move-in! Set on a beautifully landscaped 1-acre lot in the sought-after Seneca Pines subdivision of Pinetop, this exceptional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath timber frame home blends rustic mountain character with high-quality craftsmanship and modern comfort. Built by Northwoods Joinery of Burlington, Vermont, the home was thoughtfully designed with energy efficiency, low maintenance living, and Firewise principles, offering both beauty and peace of mind in a forested setting. Inside, you're immediately welcomed by dramatic 27-foot vaulted ceilings and expansive Kolbe & Kolbe windows that fill the home with natural light and frame the surrounding pines like artwork. The open-concept design creates an airy, inviting flow that feels both grand and comfortable--perfect for everyday living and entertaining alike. The primary suite is conveniently located on the main level, providing ease and privacy. Upstairs, the third bedroom includes a versatile loft space ideal for guests, a home office, creative studio, or reading retreat. A hallway lined with custom built-in bookshelves adds warmth, character, and functional storage that enhances the home's thoughtful design. Recent upgrades and system improvements provide exceptional value and year-round comfort, including a natural gas forced-air heating system (approximately 5 years old), superior insulation that maintains comfortable indoor temperatures without the need for air conditioning, and a newly updated metal roof (January 2026) with heat cables and snow rails. Even during peak summer heat--when outdoor temperatures reach the 90s--the interior keeps a cool, consistent 72°F. The oversized 2-car garage with 12-foot ceilings offers abundant storage, workshop potential, and space for all your mountain lifestyle gear--from outdoor recreation equipment to seasonal vehicles. Outdoors, the property becomes a private sanctuary. Mature landscaping, frequent wildlife visitors, and a charming treehouse tucked among the trees create a rare sense of serenity and connection to nature. With no neighbors directly behind the home, the setting offers enhanced privacy and a true feeling of retreat. Adding further value, the listing includes original construction photos and architectural plans, providing a rare opportunity to appreciate the craftsmanship and intentional design from the ground up. Centrally located in Pinetop, Arizona, this home is just minutes from Woodland Lake Park, hiking and biking trails, fishing lakes, and year-round outdoor recreation, while also offering convenient access to shopping, dining, and essential services. For winter enthusiasts, Sunrise Park Resort is only approximately 25 minutes away, making this an ideal four-season mountain home. This is a rare opportunity to own a meticulously built, thoughtfully upgraded, and truly turnkey timber frame home in one of Pinetop's most desirable neighborhoods--where comfort, craftsmanship, and mountain living come together seamlessly.

950 E Osprey Lane, Pinetop

$349,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6915710 MLS Zane Grey Acres Unit 3 SubDv. ACTIVE Status
reshly Remodeled & Full of Charm - Almost an Acre of Possibility! Step into comfort and style in this beautifully remodeled home, perfectly situated on a spacious corner lot just shy of an acre. Every inch has been thoughtfully updated, blending modern finishes with easy-living vibes that make it feel like home the moment you walk in. Inside, you'll love the new vinyl plank flooring that flows seamlessly throughout, setting the stage for a clean, cohesive look. The heart of the home - the kitchen - shines with quartz countertops, a composite under-mount sink, new cabinets, soft close drawers and a suite of brand-new appliances including a range, dishwasher, microwave, and range vent. Whether you're hosting or just making a quick bite, this kitchen is ready. The split floor-plan offers privacy and function, with a stunning custom tile shower in the primary suite, and a beautifully finished custom tile bath/shower in the guest bathroom - both topped with quartz counters for a polished feel. Other upgrades you'll appreciate: a brand-new roof, fresh interior paint, and a fenced-in patio area perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The property features mature trees offering shade and serenity, with plenty of space to stretch out, garden, or play. If you're looking for a move-in ready home that balances fresh finishes with room to breathe, this one checks all the boxes. Come see for yourself - this gem won't last long!

3149 Tonto Drive, Overgaard

$525,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6899064 MLS Holiday Forest Sub SubDv. ACTIVE Status
The proud original owners have lovingly maintained this property for years and are now ready to pass it on to someone new to enjoy and make their own. The primary manufactured home, secondary home, and RV home all can come fully furnished. Including furniture, curtains, smart TVs, decor, appliances, washer/dryer, and even kitchen essentials can all be included. This is a truly turn key, move-in-ready opportunity waiting for its next owner to enjoy from day one! Nestled on 1.82 scenic acres in beautiful Heber-Overgaard, this one-of-a-kind property offers well-maintained multi-residence property featuring a beautifully updated primary manufactured home, a 2-bedroom mobile home, and a fully equipped RV home. Main Home built in 2005 30' x 64' roof was replaced in 2024. Recently updated with new interior/exterior paint, granite bathroom counters, new toilets, faucets, dishwasher, water heater and more. Brand new washer and dryer installed for buyers convenience. Master bedroom features oversized master tub, separate shower and dual vanities. Enjoy outdoor living with a spacious Trex wrap-around deck and a charming front porch, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The beautifully landscaped front and back yards are adorned with mature pine trees, lush plants, and well-maintained shrubs. Three storage sheds (two with new roofs), and a two-car garage with a working electric opener. Second 1959 Mobile Home 10' x 50'. Features 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom with redwood deck, awnings, vinyl/carpet flooring, and furnished with beds, TV, couch, and microwave. Exterior was painted in 2023, roof coated in 2022. RV 1965 Home 32' x 8'. Includes a bedroom, kitchen, dinette, and full bath setup. Features laminate counters, microwave, and more. Recently painted with updated interior touch-ups. This unique property offers a rare combination of upgraded living spaces, versatile guest accommodations, and beautifully landscaped outdoor areas. Whether you're looking for a primary residence with additional units or a family retreat this one has it all, ready for you to move in and enjoy!

2884 Pine Rim Road, Overgaard

Start Your Search

All information should be verified by the recipient and none is guaranteed as accurate by ARMLS. Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Cabins in Payson for sale - Cabins for sale in Arizona - Cabins for sale on the river Payson, AZ

     

 

Payson Arizona Trail to home | Payson Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Real Estate

Search homes for sale in Payson AZ. Find your dream home with our extensive and complete listings, including a mortgage calculator.

The Payson area is a beautiful place to live for those who enjoy the great outdoors. There is plenty of both mountain scenery and desert landscapes to explore. The town itself has many unique shops, restaurants, and galleries. There are also plenty of outdoor activities that are available year-round, from skiing and snowshoeing in the winter months to horseback riding and hiking through the mountains in the warmer spring and summer months.

Payson AZ homes for sale near White Horse Lake offer residents access to all kinds of outdoor recreational activities with easy access to trails, fishing, boating, camping areas, and more.

Find your dream home

With thousands of listings, scottschulte.com is the best place to find your new home. Search homes by price, location, or the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Check out our mortgage calculator to see what you can afford!

Contact us for more info

We're always happy to help you find what you're looking for. Contact us today and we'll be in touch soon!

A Paradise for Outdoor Adventurers

Payson is nestled within the tall, fragrant Ponderosa Pines, and the nearby Tonto National Forest provides easy access to all kinds of outdoor recreation. Bird watching, hiking, horseback riding, hunting, mountain biking are just a few.

Fishing and kayaking are available at any of the nearby lakes, such as Bear Canyon Lake, Woods Canyon Lake, or the lakes at Green Valley Park. The area around Payson is also great for rock hounds. Very high-quality quartz crystals can be found, as well as agate, geodes, and onyx. You can also find fossils along State Route 87 and State Route 260 west of town.

Payson also has three golf courses and the Mazatzal Casino, operated by the Tonto Apache, on their reservation near the south end of town. To put it simply, Payson has all the fun activities you love. Likewise, it’s in the heart of Arizona puts you within a 2-hour drive of everything else this state has to offer.

Steeped in Western Heritage

The town was founded in 1882, and the annual “August Doin’s Rodeo” is the oldest continuous rodeo in the country, and has been held ever since 1884. The event kicks off with a parade down Main Street and features food, music and of course, a rodeo. In May, the Gary Hardt Memorial Rodeo takes place at the Multi-Purpose Event Center, across the road from the Tonto Apache Indian Reservation.

In addition to the rodeo, Payson set the stage for author Zane Grey’s many popular Western novels. Grey first passed through Payson in 1918, and eventually purchased 120-acres of Payson AZ real estate along Tonto Creek.

The town has quite a few art galleries specializing in Western art, and for those who love Old-Timey music, Payson hosts the annual Arizona State Championship Old-Time Fiddlers Contest in September.

Living in Payson is Cool!

Whether you’re young or retired, Payson offers a lot to anyone who savors the small-town lifestyle. Payson AZ real estate is appreciating fast, averaging 7% year over year. That means Homes for sale in Payson may be a good investment in the years to come. If you’ve been thinking about moving to Payson, now is the time to buy a home here.

The lifestyle is both slower and more active than a big city like Phoenix, and the weather is nicer. If you savor hiking, biking, and fishing under the pines, consider looking into homes for sale in Payson.