Payson AZ Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Homes For Sale

$995,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7028331 MLS Pinetop Country Club SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Nestled on one of the most desirable roads in Pinetop Country Club, this stunning fairway home backs to Hole #7 and Tee #8 perfectly positioned to enjoy the tranquil golf course setting while maintaining privacy among the tall pines. Recently remodeled, this home blends modern comfort with classic mountain charm. The kitchen featuring all new cabinetry, countertops, high-end stainless-steel appliances, and open shelving design. The bright, airy layout invites natural light throughout, with vaulted ceilings and large windows framing the forest views. The oversized primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with abundant windows and space for a sitting area. The primary bathroom is all new, showcasing a walk-in tiled shower, jetted soaking tub, dual vanity, and update updated fixtures. Every detail from flooring, paint, to finishes within the primary bathroom has been newly refreshed inside and out. Enjoy multiple gathering areas including a living room, family room, and cozy sitting area in front of the stone fireplace. A versatile bonus room between the garage and laundry area can easily serve as a home gym, office, or storage space. Outside, the property features exceptional curb appeal with a circular driveway, a beautifully landscaped backyard with a grass lawn, patio, and mature pines, and peaceful golf course views. Additional highlights include a spacious laundry room with extra storage and a two-car garage. This exceptional home offers room to spread out, natural light in every space, and the perfect blend of privacy and golf course living right in the heart of one of the most sought-after communities in the White Mountains.

7510 Geronimo Road, Pinetop

$725,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7027642 MLS Heber SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Perched at the end of a quiet dead-end road, this beautfiful chalet-style mountain retreat captures breathtaking panoramic canyon views from nearly every angle. Set on 2.5 private acres with no HOA and horse privileges, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort, recreation, and wide-open space. National Forest access is nearby, with fishing and outdoor adventures waiting about half hour down the road at Willow Lake, Woods Canyon Lake, and Black Canyon Lake. Inside, soaring ceilings and walls of windows create a bright and inviting atmosphere, while the open-concept kitchen and great room make gathering with family and friends effortless. The main-level primary suite offers convenience and privacy, with heated tile floors adding a touch of luxury to the full bathrooms. Downstairs the fun continues with an expansive game room featuring a wet bar, gas fireplace, home theater system with surround sound and projection screen, plus two additional bedrooms and a full bath--ideal for guests or multi-generational living. A secure storage room with keypad access and additional under-stair storage provide plenty of space for gear and essentials. Step outside onto the oversized covered decks on both levels and take in the sweeping views, cool mountain air, and peaceful setting. Whether you're enjoying morning coffee, sunset dinners, or entertaining under the stars, the outdoor spaces are designed to be enjoyed year-round. This property comes mostly furnished and is packed with thoughtful upgrades and amenities including central heating and air with Nest controls, stainless steel appliances, tankless water heater, Starlink internet, Tesla/EV charging station, Ring doorbell, owned propane tank, and a shared well system with water storage, UV filtration, and heater. The grounds are equally impressive with horseshoe pits, sandbox, paintball course, and room to roam. Private gated access, a newer roof, pantry storage, game closet, and no HOA make this one-of-a-kind property a rare opportunity for those seeking privacy, views, and adventure--all in one unforgettable mountain getaway.

1730 Persimmon Lane, Heber

$799,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 7027009 MLS Woodland Hills SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Luxury mountain retreat nestled among towering ponderosa pines in the heart of Pinetop's Woodland Hills. Experience elevated cabin living where timeless mountain charm meets comfort, privacy, and relaxation. Inside, soaring vaulted wood ceilings and an expansive open-concept Great Room create a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for entertaining. Enjoy evenings by the brick gas fireplace, peaceful mornings on the extended covered porches, and year-round enjoyment with a spacious bonus game room and enclosed Arizona room that seamlessly blends indoor and outdoor living. This 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom retreat features a split primary suite with private porch access, spa-inspired bath with jetted tub, separate shower, dual vanities, and walk-in closet. The open kitchen offers an island, walk-in pantry, oak cabinetry, gas range, built-in microwave, extended front and back porches, towering ponderosa pines, upstairs guest suite with adjacent full bath, furniture available on separate bill of sale. Located near Woodland Lake Park with pickleball, tennis courts, frisbee golf, scenic walking trails, fishing pier, playgrounds, and year-round outdoor recreation. Hiking, golf, lakes, skiing, dining, boutique shopping, and the premier lifestyle amenities make Pinetop one of Arizona's most sought-after luxury cabin destinations. Ideal for both primary and second-home buyers, mountain retreat seekers, vacation homeowners, and those looking for an exceptional White Mountains escape.

710 E Osprey Lane, Pinetop

$415,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7026326 MLS Trailwood Unit 1 SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Searching for a fully furnished 3-bed home in Payson, AZ with no HOA and easy access to outdoor recreation? Welcome Home to 905 W Prairie Road, a move-in ready single family residence offering comfort, convenience, and mountain town charm. This 3-bed, 2-bath home features 1,320sqft of inviting living space with laminate flooring throughout the living room, dining area, and hallway, soft carpet in the bedrooms, tile flooring, & granite countertops for a stylish finish. The spacious primary suite provides comfort and privacy, while the attached 2-car garage includes extra storage space for tools, gear, or seasonal items. Enjoy additional driveway and street parking plus a location near Rumsey Park, perfect for evening strolls, outdoor activities, and enjoying the fresh Payson air year-round! Welcome to 905 W Prairie Road in Payson, AZ. This fully furnished 3-bedroom, 2-bath single family residence combines comfort, practicality, and mountain town charm in a convenient location close to Rumsey Park. Built in 1995 and offering 1,320 sqft on a 6,098 sqft lot, this home is ideal for full-time living, a weekend retreat, or an investment opportunity with no HOA restrictions. Inside, the spacious layout features laminate flooring throughout the living room, dining area, and hallway, creating a warm and low-maintenance living space. The bedrooms offer soft carpeting for added comfort, while tile flooring and granite countertops add durability and style in key areas of the home. The fully furnished interior includes quality furnishings from Ashley Furniture Store, including the living room furniture (TV excluded) and an expandable dining room set that seats up to 8 guests, making the home move-in ready from day one. The kitchen opens naturally into the main living spaces, creating a connected and inviting atmosphere for everyday living or entertaining. The primary suite offers privacy and functionality with its own full bathroom and comfortable layout. Additional included appliances feature an LG washer and dryer plus two refrigerators, including one in the kitchen and an additional refrigerator in the garage for extra storage and convenience. Outside, enjoy a manageable lot with room to relax and take advantage of Payson's fresh mountain air and four-season lifestyle. The attached 2-car garage includes additional storage space, plus driveway and street parking for guests or extra vehicles. Located near Rumsey Park, this home offers convenient access to walking paths, recreation, local events, and outdoor enjoyment, including space to enjoy evening strolls with four-legged family members. Whether you are searching for a primary residence, seasonal escape, or furnished mountain getaway, this property delivers comfort, convenience, and value in one of Payson's desirable locations.

905 W Prairie Road, Payson

$395,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 7025842 MLS Mogollon Rim Addition Plat 5 SubDv. ACTIVE Status
Welcome to 212 E McKamey St, a rare flat lot in the heart of Payson that offers the kind of usable outdoor space buyers are always searching for. The property sits on a beautifully treed parcel, giving you shade, privacy, and that peaceful Rim Country feel the moment you arrive. With its level terrain and generous outdoor space, you'll have endless room for gardens, outdoor living, or future expansion. Inside, the home features a spacious living room that serves as a comfortable gathering space--perfect for relaxing, entertaining, or simply enjoying the natural light that filters in from the surrounding trees. Multiple outbuildings (450sqft and 225 sqft) add even more value, offering excellent storage and exciting potential for workshops, hobby areas, or future improvements. ...see more Welcome to 212 E McKamey St, a rare flat lot in the heart of Payson that offers the kind of usable outdoor space buyers are always searching for. The property sits on a beautifully treed parcel, giving you shade, privacy, and that peaceful Rim Country feel the moment you arrive. With its level terrain and generous outdoor space, you'll have endless room for gardens, outdoor living, or future expansion. Inside, the home features a spacious living room that serves as a comfortable gathering space--perfect for relaxing, entertaining, or simply enjoying the natural light that filters in from the surrounding trees. Multiple outbuildings (450sqft and 225 sqft) add even more value, offering excellent storage and exciting potential for workshops, hobby areas, or future improvements. This kind of space and land is rare in the heart of Payson, come and see before its gone!

212 E Mckamey Street, Payson

Start Your Search

All information should be verified by the recipient and none is guaranteed as accurate by ARMLS. Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Cabins in Payson for sale - Cabins for sale in Arizona - Cabins for sale on the river Payson, AZ

     

 

Payson Arizona Trail to home | Payson Homes For Sale

Payson AZ Real Estate

Search homes for sale in Payson AZ. Find your dream home with our extensive and complete listings, including a mortgage calculator.

The Payson area is a beautiful place to live for those who enjoy the great outdoors. There is plenty of both mountain scenery and desert landscapes to explore. The town itself has many unique shops, restaurants, and galleries. There are also plenty of outdoor activities that are available year-round, from skiing and snowshoeing in the winter months to horseback riding and hiking through the mountains in the warmer spring and summer months.

Payson AZ homes for sale near White Horse Lake offer residents access to all kinds of outdoor recreational activities with easy access to trails, fishing, boating, camping areas, and more.

Find your dream home

With thousands of listings, scottschulte.com is the best place to find your new home. Search homes by price, location, or the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Check out our mortgage calculator to see what you can afford!

Contact us for more info

We're always happy to help you find what you're looking for. Contact us today and we'll be in touch soon!

A Paradise for Outdoor Adventurers

Payson is nestled within the tall, fragrant Ponderosa Pines, and the nearby Tonto National Forest provides easy access to all kinds of outdoor recreation. Bird watching, hiking, horseback riding, hunting, mountain biking are just a few.

Fishing and kayaking are available at any of the nearby lakes, such as Bear Canyon Lake, Woods Canyon Lake, or the lakes at Green Valley Park. The area around Payson is also great for rock hounds. Very high-quality quartz crystals can be found, as well as agate, geodes, and onyx. You can also find fossils along State Route 87 and State Route 260 west of town.

Payson also has three golf courses and the Mazatzal Casino, operated by the Tonto Apache, on their reservation near the south end of town. To put it simply, Payson has all the fun activities you love. Likewise, it’s in the heart of Arizona puts you within a 2-hour drive of everything else this state has to offer.

Steeped in Western Heritage

The town was founded in 1882, and the annual “August Doin’s Rodeo” is the oldest continuous rodeo in the country, and has been held ever since 1884. The event kicks off with a parade down Main Street and features food, music and of course, a rodeo. In May, the Gary Hardt Memorial Rodeo takes place at the Multi-Purpose Event Center, across the road from the Tonto Apache Indian Reservation.

In addition to the rodeo, Payson set the stage for author Zane Grey’s many popular Western novels. Grey first passed through Payson in 1918, and eventually purchased 120-acres of Payson AZ real estate along Tonto Creek.

The town has quite a few art galleries specializing in Western art, and for those who love Old-Timey music, Payson hosts the annual Arizona State Championship Old-Time Fiddlers Contest in September.

Living in Payson is Cool!

Whether you’re young or retired, Payson offers a lot to anyone who savors the small-town lifestyle. Payson AZ real estate is appreciating fast, averaging 7% year over year. That means Homes for sale in Payson may be a good investment in the years to come. If you’ve been thinking about moving to Payson, now is the time to buy a home here.

The lifestyle is both slower and more active than a big city like Phoenix, and the weather is nicer. If you savor hiking, biking, and fishing under the pines, consider looking into homes for sale in Payson.