Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$985,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6587911 MLS ⋅ Lamar Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
UNICORN ALERT! Welcome to the 1927 Lamar Building, a historic gem of 1920's Phoenix. This two-story wire-cut brick structure underwent meticulous relocation and restoration in 2004 to become the charming townhome it is today. You are greeted at the front stoop with views of the gleaming hardwood floors, high ceilings, fantastic walls of windows allowing for lots of natural light to show this place off. Updated kitchen with custom cabinets and all views look over the fabulous back yard with a pool/spa/firepit/BBQ area..it really is the perfect yard for all seasons! Upstairs are the bedrooms, the primary is huge with treetop views and 2 walk in closets. The 2nd bedroom had a bonus area, perfect for an office w/ amazing downtown skyline views. Walk to Hance Park, Japanese Garden & more!

303 W Latham Street, Phoenix
$499,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6587773 MLS ⋅ Summit At Copper Square Condominium 2nd Amd SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Downtown living at its finest. This unit has it ALL. Its got the views, MASSIVE private balcony, the location, the tall windows, the amenities AND it is the one and ONLY unit in the ENTIRE building that has its own PRIVATE entrance to the pool. All utilities included with HOA fees!

310 S 4th Street Unit 501, Phoenix
$1,630,000
6586043 MLS ⋅ Del Rey Lots 101-140 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Great opportunity to own two Flex commercial buildings that front McDowell Road with a combined total of 8,848 sf. The property is ideal for a fractional owner user or as an investment. The large building has 2 stories and currently consists of 90% office space and 10% warehouse. There is 22' clearance height in the warehouse with a grade level roll up door plus a mezzanine for extra storage. It is fully occupied with 2 tenants in place. One lease is until December 2024 and the other is month to month. Value add property. Potential uses include but not limited to the following: Executive office suites, Medical offices, Warehouse, Distribution , Assisted living, R&D, Retail, Church, Vocational School and more. Centrally located in Phoenix on the corner of E. McDowell Road and N. 27th Street. Close proximity to Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport, Downtown Phoenix, Arcadia, Scottsdale, Downtown Tempe, Downtown Phoenix with great dining and entertainment optiions... all within 10 minutes drive!

2641 E Mcdowell Road, Phoenix
$675,000
6585836 MLS ⋅ Sunny Side Tract SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This 14,202 square-foot building, previously used as a church, presents a rare adaptive use opportunity in the Garfield Historic District, situated just East of Downtown Phoenix. Just a few blocks from Roosevelt Row, its location offers convenient access to various amenities & activities in vibrant Downtown Phoenix. The property holds significant potential for creative investors or users looking to add value and transform the space to cater to modern demands. With its unique features and position in a sought-after neighborhood, this property offers a promising prospect for those seeking a well-located and versatile real estate investment. The owner of the property adjacent to the east will entertain selling their property. This acquisition would create additional parking possibilities.

1102 E Garfield Street, Phoenix
$245,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6585489 MLS ⋅ Embassy Condominiums SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
SELLER IS WILLING TO OFFER CONCESSIONS. Looking for a comfortable living space to stay in? This simple yet stylish one-bedroom apartment w/a balcony is the one! Embassy Condominiums highlights a carpeted lobby w/adorning mirrored walls, plush seating areas, & warm lighting, creating a welcoming ambiance. Venturing upstairs, you'll find the spacious living room w/a neutral palette complementing the large windows, allowing natural light to flood. The modest galley kitchen boasts white shaker cabinets, granite counters space, & a walk-in pantry. The bedroom is conveniently adjacent to the full bathroom. You'll love sipping your cup of coffee on this relaxing balcony while overlooking the stunning views of the city skyline. Various amenities include a rooftop terrace, heated pool/spa, & more

805 N 4th Avenue Unit 207, Phoenix
$575,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6585199 MLS ⋅ Portland On The Park Condominiums 1st Amd SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Look what we have here! Behold, the epitome of architectural design and luxurious urban living at Portland On The Park! Get ready to be blown away by this exceptional club level 12th story unit. This unit is in the ''22 Stack''; highly coveted floorplan, you rarely see this one pop up. And guess what? You get not one, but TWO parking spots! Plus, no need to worry about your upstairs neighbors making noise, because there is nobody above you! But wait, there's more! As you step inside, prepare to have your mind blown by the spectacular, jaw-dropping views from the North-facing floor to ceiling windows. Whether you prefer the stunning skyline view overlooking the lush park and gardens below or the glorious beauty of Arizona's sunsets and the Camelback Mountains; your living space will be transformed into a magnificent showcase. Oh, and don't even get me started on the meticulously crafted floor plan designed with your comfort and entertainment in mind. The kitchen is a true cook's haven, equipped with updated stainless steel appliances that perfectly complement the sleek and modern design. And the private primary bedroom is a serene escape, complete with dark-out curtain for a restful night's sleep. And let's not forget about the array of amenities that come with living at Portland on the Park. Take in the breathtaking panoramic views of the city from the exclusive rooftop terrace, complete with a glass gas fire pit, BBQs, and more. Stay active in the state-of-the-art fitness center, or relax in the private pool surrounded by lush greenery and tranquility. So, what are you waiting for? Indulge in the height of luxury and elevate your lifestyle with this incredible living experience. Come on over, kick back, and create some unforgettable memories in your new home sweet home. Wanna venture away from home? There are TONS of bars and restaurants within walking distance.. very cool downtown vibe for sure. Got a pooch? This community is VERY dog friendly too! Welcome FIDO. =

200 W Portland Street Unit 1222, Phoenix
$280,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6585187 MLS ⋅ Gilbert Square SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This charming 3 bedroom, 1 bath house is located in the heart of downtown Phoenix, just steps away from all the action. The house has been recently renovated and features new stucco, a fresh coat of paint, new flooring, updated appliances and more. The backyard is perfect for entertaining, grilling, and plenty of space to run around. This house is perfect for a new family who wants to be close to all the best that downtown Phoenix has to offer

1133 W Mohave Street, Phoenix
$495,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6583101 MLS ⋅ Artisan Lofts On Central Phase 1 Condominium SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This urban chic loft is a prime property located in downtown Phoenix, offering a stunning view of the city landscape. Situated in close proximity to dining and shopping options, it provides convenience and accessibility. With its desirable location and modern design, this loft is a great investment opportunity for those seeking a vibrant urban lifestyle. The roofdeck offers spectacular view of the down town Phoenix skyline

1326 N Central Avenue Unit 202, Phoenix
$300,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6583042 MLS ⋅ Las Casitas SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
CLEAN TOWNHOME, spacious 2 bedroom plus bonus room, 1.5 bathroom, move-in ready townhome in Central Phoenix! currently been use as a ab&b, Come relax and entertain in your private block-fenced courtyard! Near downtown PHX, restaurants, shopping, coffee shops, sporting events, concerts, Sky Harbor Airport, and I-10 and SR51 expressways!

1340 E Brill Street Unit 5, Phoenix
$265,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6581812 MLS ⋅ Las Flores SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This charming 2 bedroom 1 bath bungalow is located in the historic district just minutes from downtown Phoenix. This 1946 home was completely restored and remodeled in 2020, Full restoration included all new plumbing, including the sewer line, all new electrical, new subfloor where needed with new luxury vinyl flooring, completely new bathroom and kitchen. new roof, The stone siding was restored. New AC unit and windows Large back yard for future growth, Zoned Multifamily so bring in a tiny house or build on for investment rental.

1631 W Roosevelt Street, Phoenix
$1,500,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6581428 MLS ⋅ Portland Place Condominiums Phase 1 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
*PROPERTY RECENTLY APPRAISED FOR OVER LIST PRICE - SELLER CARRYBACK OPTION AVAILABLE.** THIS GORGEOUS 2 BEDROOM PLUS DEN AND LOFT AREAS, 2.5 BATHROOM CORNER PENTHOUSE UNIT OFFERS DOWNTOWN LIVING AT ITS VERY FINEST! NESTLED IN THE HEART OF DOWNTOWN'S ROOSEVELT NEIGHBORHOOD AND ARTS DISTRICT AND SITUATED BETWEEN PORTLAND PARK AND THE JAPANESE FRIENDSHIP GARDENS. YOU WILL BE IMMEDIATELY WOWED AS YOU ENTER THROUGH THE FRONT DOOR INTO THE LARGE FOYER TO SEE 28' FLOOR TO CEILING GLASS WALLS WITH STUNNING VIEWS THAT GO PAST UPTOWN, MOUNTAINS AND THE JAPANESE GARDENS. THE VIEWS ARE ENDLESS! THE GREAT ROOM FEATURES A TWO-STORY SLATE 2-WAY FIREPLACE THAT TRAVELS ALL THE WAY UPSTAIRS TO THE MASTER SUITE. FLOOR-TO-CEILING WINDOWS THAT PROVIDE 270 DEGREE VIEWS OF THE PHOENIX AREA. TRAVERTINE FLOORING IN ALL THE MAIN LIVING AREAS. CONTEMPORARY KITCHEN WITH TOP-OF-THE-LINSTAINLESS STEEL VIKING APPLIANCES, 5-BURNER GAS RANGEGAS RANGE, SOAPSTONE COUNTERTOPS AND BACKSPLASH, LARGE WALK-IN PANTRY, AND A KITCHEN ISLAND WITH EAT-UP BAR SEATING AND PENDANT LIGHTING. THE MODERN CABLE RAILING STAIRCASE TIES INTO THE OPEN FLOOR CONCEPT OF THE UNIT LEADING YOU TO AN UPSTAIRS LOFT AND BEDROOMS. THE MASTER SUITE FEATURES GLASS WALLS INTO THE LOFT AREA. THE SPA-LIKE MASTER BATH HAS DOUBLE SINKS WITH A GLASS MOSAIC WALL BACKSPLASH WITH LED MIRRORS, A LUXURIOUS SOAKING TUB AND A GLASS ENCLOSED WALK-IN SHOWER. COMMUNITY UNDERGROUND PARKING INCLUDED WITH ASSIGNED SPOTS. THE PLETHORA OF AMENITIES AT PORTLAND PLACE INCLUDE A ROOFTOP DECK WITH POOL, BBQ GRILLING STATIONS AND ENDLESS CITY LIGHT VIEWS TO ENJOY AND ENTERTAIN! JUST MINUTES AWAY FROM ARTS, SPORTS, FINE DINING, SHOPPING, LIGHT RAIL STATION, ASU AND SKY HARBOR INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT FOR YOUR CONVENIENCE! ALSO AVAILABLE FOR RENT - PLEASE CONTACT FOR DETAILS.

208 W Portland Street Unit 557, Phoenix
$240,000
6580801 MLS ⋅ East Grier Place SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Great Opportunity for Owner/User or Developer,(2) commercial lots sold together for a total of 12,000+sq ft. Lots are zoned C-2, Allowing for an abundant of uses,High traffic counts on Buckeye Rd and less than +/- 2 miles from Chase Stadium. Located in an Opportunity zone. Close to downtown Phoenix, Chase Field, Talking Stick Arena with easy access to the I-10 and I-17.Don't miss out on this amazing opportunity. Possible seller carry back, call for more details. Debris on property/land will be removed prior to COE.Motivated seller bring your offer now! Feel free to ask for help putting an offer together.

1005 S 17th Avenue Unit -, Phoenix
$250,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6580133 MLS ⋅ Residency At Verde Park Condominiums Amd SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Welcome to ''Residency at Verde Park'' in the historic Garfield neighborhood! This unique SE facing ground floor ''B'' Floor Plan is fully upgraded with luxury vinyl plank flooring, custom white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, designer lighting, keyless entry doors, and interior laundry. Enjoy fantastic park and city light views from your front porch! Tucked in the back of the complex just steps from your parking with exterior access to unit or interior hallways front door. With 2x6 construction and noise reduction materials, these condos offer premium quality. Walk to the park, light rail, ASU/UofA, Gallo Blanco, Welcome Diner, or scooter to Roosevelt Row for a fun night out. Own a condominium in this vibrant city!

475 N 9th Street Unit 106, Phoenix
$585,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 6579602 MLS ⋅ Capitol Addition Blocks 43 & 44 35-38 29 & 30 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
REMODEL - MULTI FAMILY HOME - The main house has a 3 Bedroom with 2 Bath with new Cabinets & Walk In Pantry, interior/exterior painting, both baths have shower tile surrounds, Wood laminate planks throughout, New extended carport covers. The property has two addition units of 1 Bed/ 1 Bath each that are rented out, both units have been remodel with new cabinets, updated countertops, interior/exterior painting, Separate Laundry facility for all units to use. All units have new Roof, New Dual pane windows & New AC Unit, New Permitted Electrical Panel, Permit for future carport 25x14, Great Investment and it's permitted! YOU CAN PURCHASE THIS HOME WITH UPTO 2% LOWER INTEREST RATE!!

2025 W Jefferson Street, Phoenix
$150,000
6579229 MLS ⋅ Montgomery Add Blks 23-26, 31-34, 39-42, 47-50 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
FANTASTIC INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY WITH OPTION TO BUILD MULTI FAMILY OR SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE WITH WATER/POWER/SEWER/GAS ON SITE!!! ACROSS THE STREET FROM HARMON PARK, PUBLIC LIBRARY AND HOSPITAL. LESS THAN 2 MILES FROM DOWNTOWN PHOENIX WITH ACCESS TO ALL DOWNTOWN AMENITIES SUCH AS ASU-downtown, CHASE FIELD, FOOTPRINT CENTER, CITY SCAPE, RESTAURANTS, SHOPPING, ENTERTAINMENT, CONVENTION CENTER AND LIGHT RAIL. EASY ACCESS TO I-17 AND I-10 FREEWAYS. DRIVE BY TODAY!!

1115 S Montezuma Avenue Unit 7, Phoenix
$275,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6578422 MLS ⋅ Renaissance Park Phase 2 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Wow, this large one bedroom corner unit condo in a fantastic location downtown Phoenix. It is in the most relaxing location in the complex overlooking ponds w/waterfalls & bridges. You would not believe you're in the heart of the city. Granite countertops, travertine flooring,wood blinds & remodeled bathroom. Huge bedroom w/large walk in closet. Extra storage on the first floor. This gated community includes heated pool & spa, club room, gym & mature landscaping. Walk to ASU Downtown, U of A Medical Building, Chase Field, Talking Stick Arena, Hospitals, Convention Center & 20+ restaurants within blocks. Next to 2 light rail stations, 1 mile from I-10, 3 miles to Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport! Great price for a stellar location spot!

101 N 7th Street Unit 252, Phoenix
$600,000
6577882 MLS ⋅ Highland Addition Lots 9-26, 43-60, 74-91 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Huge Price Improvement! Duplex in Garfield Historic District Zoned R-5 (Residential or Professional Offices). Both units are remodeled and move in ready, so you can start generating income immediately. Roof, drywall, electrical, plumbing, flooring, water heater and appliances all recently upgraded! Property is perfect for students, business travelers, traveling nurses, or people looking to enjoy the trending Roosevelt & downtown night scene.

1031 E Roosevelt Street, Phoenix
$582,500
6577265 MLS ⋅ North Elsinore Block 13-14 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This charming remodeled home offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms plus two separate units in the back. Each unit features one bedroom and one bathroom. The main house has undergone extensive upgrades, boasting wood like floors, modern cabinets, and beautiful countertops. Enjoy the abundance of natural light that streams through the new dual-pane windows. The home is available fully furnished on a separate bill of sale. With its prime location, modern upgrades, and the potential for rental income, this beautiful remodeled home in Phoenix is truly a rare find.

2525 E Willetta Street, Phoenix
$165,000
6576203 MLS ⋅ H Grays Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Seller is selling 4 lots in total. 112-04-023, 112-04-025, 112-04-027. Zoned R-5 & C-2. Combined they make up 11,500 Sq.Ft. Building a multilevel, multi-family property. Additionally a 4th lot immediately behind these three lots, 112-04-067 could also be included in the sale. Multiple possibilities. All level lots just in need of a purpose

121 N 10th Avenue Unit 19, Phoenix
$468,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6574800 MLS ⋅ Kenwood Blocks 4 & 5 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
***DOWNTOWN PHOENIX - KISSING CORONADO***Here's a slice of the 1920's surrounded by historic neighborhoods. Completely remodeled in 2017, this show-stopper is 97 years old with all the charm of an early century Tudor and newer modern interior finishes. Located on a center-subdivision lot position with N/S exposure, you really have to tour it to get the entire picture. Front porch entry leads to family room and brick fireplace with wrought iron banister staircase. Eat-in kitchen has white cabinetry, quartz countertops and stainless appliances plus inside laundry. There are two bedrooms downstairs serviced by a tiled hall bath and upgraded fixtures. Up the beautiful staircase is the master suite with private ¾ bath. Zoned R-3 with big back yard and 2 car garage. This is a must see!

1521 E Brill Street, Phoenix
$285,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6573530 MLS ⋅ Sunbeam 1 Blk 5-8, 13, 14 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Great opportunity for someone to put in some sweat equity, vision & creativity and call this house their HOME.... A solid block 3 bed 1 bath house with a permitted 21' x 34' solid block detached 2 car garage with electricity, phone line & a bathroom at one time that could possibly be turned into a casita. Sits on a larger corner lot. Major items such as the plumbing was done in the kitchen and bathroom in 2008, the A/C/Ducting & heating were completely done in 2018, the roof was completely done on the house in 2013 and the kitchen & bathroom were updated in 2008. Conveniently located close to freeways, the light rail and many eateries. So don't miss out, as houses in this area don't come on the market often and when they do, they go FAST!!!

3446 E Fillmore Street, Phoenix
$435,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6573455 MLS ⋅ Oakland SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Remodeled single-level home in Phoenix is now on the market! This 3 bed, 2 bath property offers a low-care landscape, plenty of gated parking space, and a cozy porch where you can sit & sip your morning coffee. Perfectly flowing open layout features wood-look floors, fresh & clean paint, recessed lighting, a handsome accent wall, and a wood-burning fireplace, creating a warm & inviting atmosphere in the living area. Spotless kitchen boasts white shaker cabinets, stainless steel appliances, granite counters, and a breakfast bar. Continue to the main suite showcasing an immaculate ensuite w/dual sinks. All bedrooms are provided with soft carpet for warmth & comfort underfoot. The backyard has an RV gate and so much space to play. Don't miss this amazing chance!

418 N 17th Avenue, Phoenix
$255,000
6572983 MLS ⋅ Capitol Addition SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Prime MULTIfamily investment opportunity! Located at 2005 W Adams St, Phoenix, this corner lot with MULTIfamily zoning offers immense potential. West of downtown, it provides easy access to I-17 and I-10. Not in a flood zone, this R-3 zoned land has potential for up to 6 units. Develop a low-density MULTIfamily community in a thriving area near amenities and transport links.

2005 W Adams Street Unit -, Phoenix
$320,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6572077 MLS ⋅ Embassy Condominiums SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Experience the $Million view for much less! Great end-unit with wrap-around views of downtown and uptown. Unit features exposed concrete floors and ductwork, and stainless steel appliances. Community resort style pool with a patio filled with umbrellas and seating, perfect for entertaining + rec room & private gym + covered parking. HOA fees include water, HVAC, and electric. Excellent opportunity for fix and flip.

805 N 4th Avenue Unit 702, Phoenix
$462,000
6569911 MLS ⋅ H Grays Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Historic Duplex in Downtown Phoenix. Two Large One-Bedroom / One-Bathroom Units. Both Units Renovated & Completely Modernized With New Flooring, Cabinets, Countertops, & Stainless Steel Appliances .Walking Distance to the Grand Avenue Arts District.Minutes to the Nearest Light Rail Station.Less than a Mile to the Stadium District. Minutes to the ASU Downtown Campus, Crescent Ballroom, The Van Buren, & the Heart of Downtown Phoenix.Please Text for Lockbox.

146 N 10th Avenue, Phoenix
$590,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6568597 MLS ⋅ Center 8 Townhomes SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Center 8 Revival is the perfect blend of Residential and City Living in in the heart of Phoenix .The Sasquatch Development Group is pleased to introduce new homes that are simply not available in this location and price. Fantastic 3BR/3Bth plan. Two designer selected high style finish and material packages are offered as standard in all homes! Generous use of windows provide an abundance of light. Multiple outdoor spaces with balconies and a private patio courtyard and sliding patio door blends indoors and outdoors. Uniquely situated in the Roosevelt Row Arts District (RoRo) is a walkable, creative district in the urban core of downtown Phoenix that is nationally known for its arts and cultural events, fostering urban renewal and a vibrant and exciting lifestyle

825 N 9th Avenue Unit 2, Phoenix
$885,000
6567673 MLS ⋅ Kirklands Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This location says it all. Right in the heart of the ever developing area of down town Phoenix. Minutes to walk to Chase Field, Phoenix Conference Center, Museums, Restaurants and so much more. The potential use for this building is wide open, bring your creative mind! Secure parking in the rear of the building

816-818 E Washington Street, Phoenix
$1,875,000
6566556 MLS ⋅ Collins Addition Phoenix Blocks 31-34 & 39-40 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
• Great owner/user opportunity with a central location that offers convenient access to both I-10 and I-17. • Fully fenced and secured with two gated points of access for easy maneuvering thru the property. • Newly remodeled office space with new roofs and AC units.

1737 E Jackson Street, Phoenix
$475,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6565440 MLS ⋅ Security Park Annex SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Come and take a look at this brand new 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home! Located near the heart of downtown phoenix with quick access to the I10, 51, and 202 Freeways. A 2 car garage and RV gate are located on the newly built property for your convenience! Don't miss out on this beautiful new build.

2130 E Pierce Street, Phoenix
$469,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6565433 MLS ⋅ Security Park Annex SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Come take a look at this beautiful newly built, corner lot home! Located near the heart of downtown Phoenix with close access to the i10, 51, and 202 Freeways! Complete with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and a 2 car garage for your convenience. RV gate is also available at this brand new house!

2126 E Pierce Street, Phoenix

Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.