Refine Search
Sort by
$575,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6614973 MLS ⋅ Carefree Crossing SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Step into this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home with a 3-car garage and 2,415 square feet of living space, located in the Sonoran Foothills community. This property offers both privacy and stunning mountain views on a premium lot. You'll be greeted by an abundance of natural light and a modern, spacious layout with recessed lighting. Throughout the home, you'll find high-quality finishes and attention to detail. The kitchen features updated cabinets, granite countertops, and a convenient island, perfect for casual dining while overlooking the living area and elegant formal dining space. From the living room, you'll find a bright and well-proportioned office/den, a powder room, double storage closets, and a laundry area. The large Owner's Suite boasts a sitting area and a spa-like bathroom with double sinks, a separate tub and shower, and a spacious walk-in closet with plenty of shelving and storage. Enjoy the privacy of the split floorplan, which includes two comfortable guest bedrooms, a shared bath, a powder room, a generous linen closet. The oversized covered patio offers fantastic views, and the backyard has endless potential. This property is conveniently located near major highways such as I-17, the 303, 101, and 51, making it easily accessible. It's also within walking or biking distance of the new semiconductor chip factory. This home is turnkey and move-in ready!

2221 W Apache Rain Road, Phoenix

$515,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6614544 MLS ⋅ Mountain View Meadows SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Beautiful 4 Bedroom Home newly remodeled with a backyard oasis. Kitchen has a new stainless steel appliances and new quartz countertops with a breakfast bar for entertaining. Retreat to the main bedroom which offers a private exit and dual vanity sinks with a oversized walk in closet. You will love all the storage space this home has to offers, private large laundry area with additional storage just off the garage. Newly installed carpet and tile and bedrooms offer custom wood shutters. Backyard Oasis with you're own sparkly private Pool and Jacuzzi and a large grassy area for entertaining with a covered patio. Side yard also has additional parking with a RV gate. No stone left unturned with this remodel, shows light and bright and is in pristine condition.

5120 W Mercer Lane, Phoenix

$575,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6614476 MLS ⋅ Greentrails SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
PERFECT LOCATION! This move in ready single family 4Bed/2Bath Slump block home with beautiful curb appeal & N/S exposure is located just north of Lookout Mountain in the Phx-Moon Valley area & is close to shops, schools, restaurants, and gorgeous hiking trails. A community playground is down the street & a few miles away a massive semiconductor plant is being built in north Phoenix by the Taiwanese Manufacturer TSMC offering a multitude of jobs. This spacious property sits on 13,606sf giving you plenty of room to spread out & enjoy life. The oasis backyard abuts a Greenbelt & features an RV Gate, covered patio, private diving pool w/slide & variable speed pump. Lounge around the pool when it's hot or huddle up to the firepit when it's cold. The separate dog run spans the width of the

818 E Aire Libre Avenue, Phoenix

$900,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6614116 MLS ⋅ Broadmoor SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
It's not often that these one-of-a-kind Tufa stone charming cottages comes on the market in the Historic Districts. Now's your chance to own this rare unique 3 bedroom/2 bath home with owners of 25 years who have maintain historic charm while incorporating modern convenances. Refinished hardwood floors & new paint throughout. Formal living & dining rooms as well as sitting room w/fireplace off main bedroom. Fourth room can serve as multiple purposes such as office or additional living space. Updated kitchen w/island, breakfast bar & wine cooler. Primary bedroom w/remodeled ensuite bathroom & walk-in closet. Complete remodeled large hall bathroom. Tranquil back yard w/mature trees, 2 fountains for relaxation & covered patio for entertainment. Rare for Willo a 2-car garage.

502 W Monte Vista Road, Phoenix

$600,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6614072 MLS ⋅ Dobbins Creek SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Stunning two-story home on a prime corner lot in Dobbins Creek awaits you! As you approach, breathtaking mountain views, a 3-car garage, and a cozy porch welcome you to this tranquil setting. Discover a harmonious blend of tile and plush carpeting, plantation shutters, and a refreshing color palette. The open-concept of living and dining rooms ensure effortless entertaining. Designed for gatherings, the bright & airy great room showcases an impeccable kitchen complete w/wood cabinets, SS appliances, tile backsplash, & an island w/a breakfast bar. A multi-use den with built-ins is ideal for work or leisure or it could be your 6th bedroom. Double doors open to the sizable main suite providing an ensuite w/dual sinks & a generous walk-in closet. Have a fun weekend in this expansive backyard, providing a shaded patio, fire pit w/seating, a BBQ grill w/dining bar, & a sparkling blue poolall set against a backdrop of captivating mountain vistas. Don't miss this gem. Make it yours today!

1317 E Gwen Street, Phoenix

$815,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6613284 MLS ⋅ Granite Pass At The Foothills Lot 1-94 Tr A-C SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Welcome to this stunning remodeled residence nestled in the foothills of Ahwatukee. Newer AC units, double pane windows, tile floor throughout (no carpet), interior/exterior paint & roof!! Remodeled kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's dream adorned w/ gleaming granite countertops & backsplash- this space is both beautiful & functional. SS appliances add a touch of modern sophistication w/ double oven, wine fridge & a walk-in pantry. Extended family room, complete w/ a cozy fireplace. Two sets of French doors seamlessly connect the indoors to your private oversized resort backyard featuring a pool & spa, covered patio & extended deck for lounging. RV Gate w/ concrete slab, grass area & striking palm trees. Retreat to your spacious primary suite which includes a sitting room, fireplace & breathtaking mountain views from the balcony. Newly updated primary bath includes new vanity w/ quartz top, all tile shower & freestanding tub & barn door to closet. Custom paint, elegant shutters, & classy closets add an extra layer of sophistication. Your garage is an organizer's dream, featuring an epoxy floor & built-in cabinets for storage. Roof 3 yrs old. AC 4 yrs old. Side yard has storage shed too! Desert Vista High School. Kyrene School District. The Ahwatukee lifestyle is easy to access at this convient location. Just minutes from hiking, biking, parks, shopping, restaurants, banking and more. Live surrounded by protected natural spaces with all the benefits of Phoenix. 202 and I-10 freeways 20 minutes to Sky Harbor Airport. of This home exudes pride of ownership and is truly a must-see. Immerse yourself in the comfort, luxury, and convenience it offers. Your dream home in Phoenix, Arizona, is now a reality!

408 E South Fork Drive, Phoenix

$1,275,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6613165 MLS ⋅ Ty Dean Place SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Fabulous remodeled Central Corridor home w/pool and detached guest house on a 13,286 sq ft lot situated on quiet street. Classic ranch architecture, hardwood floors, wood shutters, and wood/steel Anderson window package throughout the entire 2,232 sq ft, 3 bed/2 bath main house, formal living room, large gourmet kitchen w/gas cooktop, custom cherry cabinetry, stone counters/island, double wall ovens, drawer micro, stainless appliances and much more. A wall of glass beckons outside into the large covered patio, replete with plumbed built-in gas BBQ area w/separate gas fire pit. Basket weave brick patio throughout pool deck and flows onto a lush grass lawn w/mature shade trees, & new 450 sq ft guest house/pool cabana. Low taxes, & huge, owned solar array makes this home extra affordable!

328 E Keim Drive, Phoenix

$2,100,000
6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 6612805 MLS ⋅ Rancho Del Monte SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
***Seller to make a contribution towards closing costs, pre-paid interest, and/or interest rate buy downs on attractive offers. New TJH homeowners will receive a complimentary 1-year membership to Inspirato, a leader in luxury travel. Pool to be completed mid December 2023.*** Enjoy a beautiful, open floorplan, with plenty of room for friends and family - perfect for entertaining. From a stunning front yard, you'll enter this home into a foyer that spills into a great room with a dining area and an entertainer's dream kitchen with top-of-the-line appliances and a large island. Natural wood flooring throughout main living spaces alongside clean white cabinets, tile, and quartz countertops give the space a luxurious aesthetic. The grand suite boasts a spa-like bath with dual-sinks. Upstairs, you'll discover a large bonus room and three additional bedrooms. Designed for year-round enjoyment, this farmhouse-style home seamlessly integrates indoor and outdoor living. Step out onto the covered patio to relax and relish the beautiful Arizona climate. The expansive backyard has a pool and provides plenty of room for outdoor activities. Swimming pool to be completed by mid November. This home is conveniently located within walking distance of local shops, restaurants, and lifestyle amenities!

4511 N 38th Place, Phoenix

$990,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 6612758 MLS ⋅ Sonoran Commons Phase 2 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Nestled in a serene neighborhood, this home combines modern elegance with timeless charm. As you step inside, you'll immediately notice the warm and inviting atmosphere created by the white-oak wood floors that flow throughout the main living areas adding sophistication. The kitchen boasts a spacious island with quartz countertops, perfect for chefs and entertainers. Open floor plan connects the kitchen to the living area with trendy shiplap accents. The bathrooms were recently remodeled with high-end fixtures for a spa-like experience. With 4 bedrooms and a flexible den, this home suits any lifestyle. A 3-car garage provides ample parking and storage. Outside you'll find a refreshing pool on a large lot that's perfect for cooling off and easy to maintain artificial grass and travertine.

30917 N 27th Avenue, Phoenix

$875,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6611300 MLS ⋅ Villa Valencia Lot 1-9 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
THIS IS ONE OF THOSE HOMES YOU BETTER NOT PASS ON IT. WONDERFUL N. CENTRAL LOCATION ON A REALLY COOL & PVT CUL DE SAC. LOTS OF CHARACTER AND BEAUTIFULLY LANDSCAPED FRONT YARD. HOME NEEDS SOME UPDATING BUT IS IN GOOD SHAPE. 48'' SUBZERO FRIDGE INSTALLED IN 2021. ALL DUAL PANED WINDOWS T/O. 1 AC IS 6 MONTHS OLD. ROOF WAS DONE IN 2010. SOME IRRIGATION WORK WAS DONE IN 2008. TWO BEDROOMS SHARE 1 FULL BATH.ANOTHER BDR HAS A 3/4 BATH. HUGE MASTER SUITE HAS 2 LARGE W/I CLOSETS WITH FULL BATH & DOOR TO BACKYARD. BACKYARD HAS PAVER WALKWAY, 7' PRIVACY BLOCK WALL & LOTS OF GRASS..ROOM FOR POOL IF DESIRED. FRONT YARD LOOKS LIKE A PARK WITH GRASS, MATURE TREES AND A TURF AREA FOR BEAUTY. FOR YOUR CAR COLLECTORS--2 CAR GARAGE, 6 CAR SLAB FOR PARKING AND A RV GATE AREA FOR BIGGER TOYS..DONT MISS OUT.

7814 N 4th Place, Phoenix

$252,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6610819 MLS ⋅ Shadow Mountain Villas Condominium Amd SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Location, location! Short distance to Arizona Mills Mall, Sky Harbor Airport, ASU, downtown Phoenix & Tempe, and golf course. Quietly located in the heart of the community without adjacent to any streets. Newly upgraded single story home features 2 master suites each with its own full bath that has new cabinet and countertop. No carpets on flooring and sunscreens for saving on SRP bill. Kitchen includes new quartz countertop and new cabinets, sink and plumbing fixtures, new stainless steel appliances. AC unit and water heater were replaced from the original. Community has multiple amenities: pool, spa, clubhouse, fitness center, BBQs, grassy areas. Near public transportation. Seller's home warranty of this unit will expire in May 2024 and is transferable.

3511 E Baseline Road Unit 1099, Phoenix

$560,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6609560 MLS ⋅ Foothills Club West SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Ideal location nestled in the sought after Foothills Club West community in Ahwatukee! Nearly $100K of new captivating upgrades include a new A/C, windows, partial roof, stunning LVP flooring and a REMODELED kitchen. With a picture-perfect view of the mountains from the master bedroom, you have to see this home for yourself! Venture out to the backyard where a sparkling pool and spa awaits a fun filled family outdoor experience. Outdoor activities thrive in Ahwatukee as locals living in the area have plenty of nearby attractions to enjoy at all times of the year. One of the best places to visit in Ahwatukee is the South Mountain Park and Preserve, a 16,000-acre space... with everything from mountain ranges and hiking trails to horseback riding and mountain biking paths. In 2022, Niche rated Ahwatukee #1 in Best Neighborhoods to Live in Phoenix. Award winning Kyrene School district. Desert Vista High. Community amenities include a clubhouse and park with 2 tennis/pickleball courts, 2 sand volleyball courts, 2 basketball courts, and playground equipment. Community hosts many fun events for homeowners and the area is well known for its amazing Christmas lights display. Close to shopping, restaurants, entertainment & convenient freeway access. This is a must see! Upgrades: No Items Approx Year Installed 1 Kitchen Cabinets 2020 2 Kitchen Remodeled with Backsplash 2012 3 Floors - Waterproof LVP 2020 4 New Appliances 2021 5 Updated Recessed Lightings 2021 6 Windows Replaced 2021 7 Attic Insulation with Radiant Barriers 2021 8 Remodeled all Showers 2021 9 Pool Pump 2021 10 New Carpets 2021 13 Tankless Water Heater 2023 14 Pre-Wired for An EV Vehicle Charger 2022 15 Water Softener 2012 16 Electronic Pet Door with Sensors 2020 17 Ceiling Wooden Beam 2021 18 New A/C System (In and out) Variable Speed 2022 19 Insulated Garage Door 2022

1764 W Muirwood Drive, Phoenix

$855,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6609313 MLS ⋅ Groves SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
THIS BEAUTIFUL CUSTOM HOME IS LOCATED ON ONE OF THE MOST SCIENC STREETS IN NORTH CENTRAL AND SITUATED ON A 14,734 SQFT LOT. SELLERS BOUGHT THIS HOME NINE YEARS AGO AND HAVE ADDED THE FOLLOWING NEST WIFI LEARNING THERMOSTATS, ALL SS APPLIANCES INCL. MICROWAVE, FRIDGE,WIFI OVEN,GAS RANGE & BOSCH D/W. ALSO ADDED ENERGY EFFICIENT PENTAIR SUPERFLO VARIABLE SPEED POOL PUMP,REPLACED ALL WINDOWS WITH CERTIFIED LOW W W/SOUND SUPPRESSION GLASS W/ LIFETIME WARRANTY. ALSO EV CHARGER. KITCHEN W/EAT IN AREA OPENS TO LG FAMILY ROOM W GAS FP. 10' CEILINGS T/O. 2 BDRS ARE SPLIT ON ONE SIDE OF HOME. PRIMARY STE IS SPLIT & HAS A LG W/I CLOSET. THERE ALSO IS A PVT OFFICE HERE. PARK-LIKE GRASS BACKYARD W/ MATURE TREES, HAS A GREAT YARD FOR PARTIES & PLAY, ELEC GATE W/ ROOM FOR 4-6 CARS & PLAY POOL.

719 E Circle Road, Phoenix

$960,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 6608904 MLS ⋅ Estates At Dreamy Draw Lots 1 Thru 30 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Beautifully spacious home within a small gated community, surrounded by stunning mountain views. This home features easy indoor/outdoor living and a flexible floorpan. Interior features 4 bedrooms, a great work from home office, 3.5 baths, island kitchen, double ovens, & granite countertops. Outdoors features a pool with fountain and swim-up bar, 2 ramadas, and beautiful maintenance free turf, perfect for entertaining, on an over 1/2 acre secluded lot. The roof and both a/c units are less than 3 years old, as are the water heater and all stainless kitchen appliances, including built-in refrigerator. The home is lovingly maintained, yet there is plenty of opportunity to upgrade and personalize. Nestled in a quiet community near $1.5M homes. This home embraces the best of desert and city living with hiking trails just outside the front door and easy transportation arteries that will have you into the center of the city and airport in just a matter of minutes. Home being sold "AS IS"

9446 N 25th Street N, Phoenix

$1,286,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6608107 MLS ⋅ Butler Park Estates SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Welcome to your dream home in one of the most coveted locations in Central Phoenix. Nestled in the exclusive Royal Palms Neighborhood, this custom home features excellent craftsmanship while being a private oasis. Spacious front courtyard with a firepit welcomes guests while maximizing the lot area. Home features an excellent floor plan, dramatic wood beams in the living room, hardwood floors throughout the appropriate rooms, all remodeled bathrooms, and plenty of sunlight. Chef's kitchen with a gas Viking stove and an oversized refrigerator. Large master bedroom holds a sitting area with a gas fireplace and a custom designed closet. Master bathroom has his and her sinks, new walk-in shower design, and stand alone soaking tub. The impressive resort style backyard will delight your guests with the modern pool design with water features, built in bbq island & grill, outdoor fireplace, and patio great for those famous Arizona nights. Stone tile throughout the backyard with covered pergola. Three car garage with epoxy flooring and many built in storage options. Walking distance to the beautiful green Royal Palm Park, surrounded by eclectic boutiques, locally owned restaurants and a 15 minute drive to Downtown Phoenix. Sunny slope school district one of the best in Arizona! This home with elegant form and graceful function is a must see.

1112 W El Camino Drive, Phoenix

$1,360,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 6608018 MLS ⋅ Whitcomb Roundup Ranchos SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Welcome to Whitcombs Estates (or otherwise known by the neighbors as The Circle), a quaint and wonderful neighborhood in a sought after pocket of Arcadia Lite. Walk through the front courtyard which is ideal for a fire pit with the neighbors and inside this Tuscan inspired home to be greeted with warm tones, tons of natural light, a wet bar, a media room, primary suite encompasses the entire second floor, travertine flooring, and plantation shutters throughout. The chef-inspired kitchen boasts top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances, double ovens, granite countertops, an oversized breakfast bar, and custom cabinetry. Step outside to your private oasis, featuring a covered patio, a sparkling pool, a built-in BBQ, and a meticulously landscaped backyard.

4147 N 33rd Place, Phoenix

$925,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 6607714 MLS ⋅ Stetson Valley Parcels 15-16 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
One of the largest lots in the area backing to a common greenbelt! Large 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath with wood-like tile flooring. Excellent open floorplan with extended covered patio and oversized 3 car garage. Numerous updated items include: Recent fully updated master bath remodeled with spacious walk-in shower and large walk-in closet. Custom french doors added and newer master bedroom sliders with barn door slider for privacy. Kitchen island with granite counters and upgraded appliances. Perfect entertainment backyard with custom heated pool/spa with waterfall feature and stone accents. Outdoor fireplace with sitting area and large extended covered patio. Front yard turf and courtyard area with pavers for sitting area. See supplement regarding solar and features, etc. Solar (owned) system recently installed in 2023, 11.84 DC watt system and 32 panels on roof. Solar loan will be paid by seller at closing. Osmosis system and water conditioner. Side RV gate for extra parking and storage Tuff shed. Cabinetry in garage. Pool stone just replaced. Large lot for entertaining! Privacy due to backyard being adjacent to the common greenbelt area. Must see property, too many items to list! See attached list of features, etc.

5622 W Spur Drive, Phoenix

$2,300,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6607511 MLS ⋅ Doubletree Canyon Mcr 218 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Welcome to your dream home nestled in Doubletree Canyon, right at the base of the stunning Phoenix Mountain Preserves. This exceptional 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom residence offers a perfect blend of comfort, style, and outdoor beauty. As you step inside, you'll be captivated by the exquisite wood floors and 9 ft French doors leading to a backyard oasis that includes a fire feature, sparkling pool, built in BBQ, sport court and ample patio space. The spacious living areas are flooded with natural light, making every room feel bright and airy. The heart of this home is undoubtedly the chef's kitchen with a huge butcher block island. The kitchen has top-of-the-line appliances, abundant counter space and opens to a great room surrounded by French doors. In addition to the four spacious bedrooms, this home boasts an extra-large den that can be customized to suit your needs, whether it's a home office, playroom, or home gym. Doubletree Canyon is a fantastic community that offers easy access to hiking trails, allowing you to explore the natural beauty of the Phoenix Mountain Preserves right from your doorstep. And when you're ready for some urban adventures, you'll find shopping, dining, and entertainment options just moments away

8921 N 47th Street, Phoenix

$595,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6605433 MLS ⋅ Mountain Park Ranch Unit 8b SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
This Mountain Park Ranch gem is a statement in pride of ownership, you can feel it the moment you step through the door. Let's start with the big stuff: all new windows, new roof, Pella exterior doors, high-end RO and soft water systems, custom sun screens, extra insulation in the attic...and the list goes on! Be sure to check the list of improvements in the document tab! One of the three HOA pools is just around the block and you can walk to nearby shopping and restaurants plus you're close to the 202 and the I-10 that will get you anywhere you'd like to go in the valley fast! The incredibly affordable HOA offers three pools (one heated in winter), pickle ball/tennis courts, playgrounds and lots of green space. The floorpan is a true four bedroom and 2.5 car garage with work bench & cabinets, giving you some of that always needed extra storage space. Newer stainless steel appliances, insulated garage door, epoxy garage floor, new interior door handles, plantation shutters, extra garage lighting - truly the owners have done so many extras that can be yours to enjoy from day one!

14849 S 41st Street, Phoenix

$950,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6604327 MLS ⋅ Royal Crest Villa SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
Fantastic fully remodeled home on one the best streets in North Central. The complete 2019 remodel included removing walls and opening the home up with one large great room. The living room, kitchen and dining room all open to each other and also open to the front and rear of the home. Beautiful finishes, stainless appliances and a huge island with seating for 4-6 people. One of the 2 guest bedrooms is large with a seating area. ASSUMABLE $475,000 VA LOAN AT 2.25%. The inside laundry has storage and a sink. Outside there is a fantastic fully remodeled salt water pool, covered patio and new pergola. The front patio is perfect for this street with friendly neighbors and great families. MORE on next page

737 E Hayward Avenue, Phoenix

$644,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 6603582 MLS ⋅ Lakewood Parcel 23 SubDv. ⋅ CLOSED Status
RARE opportunity to have a home in the coveted Lakewood neighborhood of Ahwatukee! This spacious home is something special from the beautifully upgraded kitchen w/ year old appliances, upgraded tile and vinyl flooring, to the awesome tri-level layout that keeps the lower level cooler in the summer & warmer in winter, to keep your power bill reasonable! Step into the backyard & you're instantly in paradise with a beautiful greenbelt view, pool, jacuzzi and pergola. Ready for you to entertain! New water heater was just installed, plus the roof and hvac to be done prior to close & include warranties. What a value! This beauty is also close to shopping, dining, walking paths, lakes you can fish, and highly rated schools! Reach out today to find about all this home has to offer!

16852 S 36th Place, Phoenix

Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.