Refine Search
Sort by
$795,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6705815 MLS Ahwatukee E-1 SubDv. CLOSED Status
Welcome! This classic custom home on nearly a 1/2 acre in Equestrian Estates has been meticulously maintained! You're greeted by a charming living/dining room with vaulted ceilings, a quaint bay window. Then enter into cozy family room with fireplace and spacious kitchen with breakfast nook, maple wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a large breakfast bar island. Sizeable primary bedroom has direct backyard access along with an ensuite with dual sinks and walk-in closet. You'll also find a separate workshop for hobbies and a Den. Magnificently landscaped backyard with a covered patio, built-in BBQ, multiple sitting areas with mountain views. Newer HVAC Units (2020/2021), Water Heater (2023), Tile T/out & many extras make this a MUST SEE! Home contains air-conditioned bonus space with outside access currently being used as a woodworking shop with high end word working tools, sink, air scrubber & dust removal system. Equipment available under separate bill of sale. HOA will allow horses on property along with tack room and stables.

12054 S Appaloosa Drive, Phoenix

$1,064,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 6699541 MLS Ahwatukee E-1 SubDv. CLOSED Status
The ultimate AZ home in coveted Equestrian Estates features an open floor plan and incredible views. The designer kitchen features premium granite slab counters, huge island, and custom wood cabinetry. Vaulted ceilings and skylights let in natural light and mountain views. The large backyard is a private oasis with real grass, including Meyer lemon and sweet orange trees, pool, large covered patio and a wall of trees that frames a South Mountain view. Full bedroom/bathroom downstairs. Massive laundry & storage room & 4-car tandem garage means you can park in the garage and still store all your toys. Walking distance to hiking trails at South Moutain. Close to tons of shopping and entertainment. HOA and city allow for casita/ADU. $10,000 seller concession for the right offer.

3844 E Equestrian Trail, Phoenix

$800,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 6693234 MLS Desert Hills SubDv. CLOSED Status
Beautiful property nestled on over 1 acre of land in Phoenix! A circular driveway, RV gate, & a spacious 3-car garage are just the beginning. Discover a welcoming open layout showcasing neutral palette, tile flooring, soft carpet in all the right places, plantation shutters, & charming arched doorways. The well-appointed kitchen boasts wood cabinetry w/crown moulding, recessed lighting, SS appliances, a pantry, sleek granite counters, a stylish tile backsplash, & a two-tier peninsula complete w/breakfast bar. The primary bedroom features private outdoor access & an immaculate ensuite w/dual sinks & a walk-in closet. The oversized backyard offers a full-length covered patio, sparkling swimming pool, putting green, fire pit, & TONS of space for anything you'd like! Don't miss this rare gem!

1510 W Joy Ranch Road, Phoenix

$1,080,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 6669571 MLS Ahwatukee E-2 Amd SubDv. CLOSED Status
Located in the Equestrian Estates Custom home neighborhood. Original Owner, the home has been meticulously maintained and updated, Great mountain views from both levels. Footsteps away from hiking and biking in the desert preserve. Large backyard for entertainment and family activities. Mature citrus trees. Recent 2nd floor remodel, renovated pool and large deck. Newer roof, well insulated home for energy savings. newer Trane variable speed hvacs. Custom knotty alder cabinets and doors, new floors, kitchen and master bedroom/bath and upstairs remodel, ionization water system, new paint, bar in family room, propane fireplaces in family room and master suite. ceiling fans throughout, Open floor plan, great neighborhood. Location, location, location!

11626 S Appaloosa Drive, Phoenix

$1,135,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 6667605 MLS Sunburst Farms 1 SubDv. CLOSED Status
*SELLER FINANCING AVAILABLE* ~Deal of the Year~ Your dream equestrian estate is here! Spoil your horses in this custom built 450k tongue-and-groove, insulated, 3,000 sq.ft. BARN with 8 enclosed stalls. Office, entertainment or tack room with locking door. Indoor space for supplies and feed. Kitchen for snacks and storage or indoor wash rack. Ring system for iinternet and, cameras. Ceiling fans, multiple electric and water sources at the barn. Each stall has a rotating feed door for easy access and auto waterers as well as doors leading out to covered paddocks which lead to green pasture.. Enjoy riding on almost 2 acres featuring 2 seeded flood-irrigation pastures, 60 x 120 arena and mature citrus orchard all pipe-fenced in. After riding, take a dip in your sparkling blue 9ft diving POOL, dine under the gazebo, cozy up with friends by the outdoor fireplace, or bring the fun inside to the fully enclosed Arizona room. Take a walk through the white picket fence and enter your charming remodeled tri-level home. This 4 bed, 2 bath features a dreamy white kitchen w/ GE appliances, moveable island, engineered hardwood floors on the open-concept main level, tile downstairs and carpet in the 2 bedrooms upstairs. Property includes 2 gates, RV 220 outlets, 6 110 outlets nearby, 220 outlet near the pool for hottub, various water spigots, over 4,000 sq ft of parking room for RVs, toys, trucks, 2 car garage with cabinets and a workbench. Home is connected to city sewer and water- No shared well agreement to worry about here! No water restrictions from the private irrigation company. Rare horse-lovers hidden gem tucked in the center of town. Act now before this gem is gone!

4210 W Acoma Drive, Phoenix

$1,255,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 6660629 MLS Ahwatukee E 4 SubDv. CLOSED Status
Step into your dream home in Equestrian Estates - a beautifully maintained customized home available at its recently appraised value. This single-story residence sits on a ½ acre lot, featuring a main house with 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, complemented by a fully furnished 1 bedroom-1 bath guest house. Enjoy exquisite mountain views surrounding the property! Inside, a chef's dream kitchen awaits, with an expansive island, top-notch appliances, and gorgeous cabinets. The open layout is perfect for daily meals or entertainment, offering expansive windows with views of the sparkling pool and mountains. Outdoors, discover a well-appointed kitchen with a top-of-the-line BBQ, wet sink, and cooler - ideal for outdoor dining or hosting gatherings. The Owner's Suite provides a retreat with backyard access, an oversized soaking tub, separate shower, dual vanities, and a spacious walk-in closet. Additional bedrooms are generously sized, and the 4th bedroom serves as a spacious office with a bonus walk-in closet. The 670 sq ft guest house offers a kitchenette, dining space, great room, full bathroom, bedroom, and workout room - perfect for guests or as an additional office. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the 3 full sized garage spaces with a separate workshop, custom cabinets, and epoxy floors. Situated by the South Mountain preserve, enjoy easy access to hiking and biking trails. Minutes from freeway access, Phoenix Sky Harbor airport, shopping, dining, and Ahwatukee's outdoor amenities. Excellent schools complete the package. Come and fall in love with this upscale community! Note: Complete List of Improvements available under Docs Tab

3716 E Ahwatukee Drive, Phoenix

$620,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6644984 MLS Metes & Bounds SubDv. CLOSED Status
Bring your toys & horses! This nice 1 acre property has room for both. 2 RV gates for easy access to the back yd. & horse pens. The home has endless possibilities. Open living, dining & kitchen area is great for entertaining. Kitchen offers plenty of counter space, newer cabinets & granite countertops w/stainless steel appliances (refrigerator included). Dining in great room w/stone fireplace plus breakfast nook. Split master bedroom has walk-in closet, full bath & 2 separate sinks. Huge air conditioned Az. room w/Saltillo tile would work great for game room, office or TV room. Includes a beautiful notty pine wet bar. Large laundry room w/sink, large pantry & room for a freezer. This corner lot includes circular drive for extra parking & 3 16x16 covered pens plus large turn out.

1426 E Cloud Road, Phoenix

$1,890,000
4 Beds 5 Baths 6641817 MLS Ahwatukee Custom Est 10 Lot 7101-7119 SubDv. CLOSED Status
First time on market! 4 bedroom/4.5 baths and office. ALL BEDROOMS ON MAIN LEVEL . Built-in maple cabinets with custom-color hand finish in many rooms. Excellent split-bedroom floorplan. Gourmet kitchen with large island, professional appliances. Upstairs game room with sitting area, bar, full bath, rooftop patio and balcony. Primary bedroom with walk-in closet, separate tub and shower. All windows dual-pane and tinted. Huge patio overlooking pool and hot tub with gazebo and sport court with amazing mountain views. Gated horseshoe driveway and separate drive to 3-car Garage with storage. Mature landscaping on cul-de-sac corner lot in premier community near trailheads to S Mtn Regional Park, :20 from Sky Harbor Airport, close to shopping, freeways. Lovingly cared-for home ready for new owner

3439 E Keresan Drive, Phoenix

$1,025,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 6638553 MLS Ahwatukee E 3 Phase 1 SubDv. CLOSED Status
Welcome to a timeless sanctuary in the heart of Equestrian Estates where old-world charm meets modern luxury in this custom-crafted residence. This enchanting home boasts four bedrooms, each uniquely designed to offer a harmonious blend of comfort and sophistication. The crowning jewel of this masterpiece is the primary bedroom, located upstairs for ultimate privacy. Step into a retreat of tranquility where a walk-out deck beckons you to unwind. From this elevated vantage point, you can take in the sprawling backyard. A sparkling pool adorned with fire wok pots, invites you for a refreshing dip, while a hot tub promises relaxation under the starlit Arizona sky. An entertainer's delight where you will find an extended patio, multiple seating areas, an outdoor fireplace and BBQ grill, and finally a putting green! Behind the home you will find easy access to horse trail! Two additional upstairs bedrooms, adorned with private balconies that provide intimate escapes with views of the surrounding beauty. Whether it's a quiet morning coffee or an evening sunset, each balcony offers a serene space to enjoy the outdoors. Downstairs you will find a spacious office which could easily be converted to a bedroom. The architectural design of the home embodies old-world charm, with details like wrought-iron accents, rustic finishes, and carefully chosen materials that evoke a sense of timeless elegance. Inside, the interiors seamlessly flow, creating an open and inviting atmosphere that encourages both relaxation and entertainment. The eat-in kitchen features a Dacor gas range and warming drawer, a pot filler, double wall ovens, and a dedicated pantry. Everything you desire whether preparing daily meals, or entertaining your guests! The formal dining room with French doors offers additional dining space and a glimpse of the living room Canterra Stone fireplace for added ambiance. The family room has a magnificent hand-crafted media center which is both functional and eye-catching. The three car garage will be the perfect place to store your cars on the distinctive Barrett Jackson flooring, a true touch of luxury for automotive enthusiasts. Welcome to a place where every detail is crafted with care, and where the timeless charm of the old-world meets the sophistication of modern luxury.

12221 S 35th Street, Phoenix

$1,250,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 6633583 MLS Desert Hills...1/2 Mile Past Desert Hills Road. 300 Yards From Maricopa Trail Gate SubDv. CLOSED Status
EXCLUSIVE. ORIGINAL DESERT HILLS HOME. Once in a lifetime opportunity! Location, Views, Convenience, Uniqueness! Gated Horse property sitting at the end of a private road. Nearby is the Maricopa Trail w horseback riding, hiking/ biking right out your front door! This home offers lots of Charm & Character. Good working horse set up w 4 stall barn & tack room/hay area. There's also a Garden area & plenty of room to park your boat and all your other toys. Lots of remodel done and newly updated paint inside and out. New door hardware, pool pump, pool decking, garage coating, roof, septic, well pump, pressure tanks...impressive list in docs tab. Workshop is being used for storage & as a home gym. Large 12x24 storage bldg plus a well house. This home offers so much bang for your buck! Don't miss the chance to buy a Desert Hills original located on hard to find 2.5 acres close to the TSMC plant and for ez commute on I-17. Albertsons, Fry's Grocery are very close as well as restaurants, shopping and The Home Depot.

414 W Ridgecrest Road, Phoenix

$825,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 6627871 MLS No Hoa- Desert Hills- County Island SubDv. CLOSED Status
Exceptional 4-bdrm territorial-style home at the end of a cul-de-sac with a perfect vantage point to soak in the views! There is a detached 250sf hobby bldg w/ electric/water,+ 2 RV gates, an arena/turnout, + 3 covered corrals. Home combines rustic charm with generous open spaces, all without the confines of an HOA. Southwestern character + style define this home beginning with granite-travertine + stainless appliance kitchen, dining and living areas all with 10' ceilings + 20'' porcelain tile. The living area opens to an expansive covered paver patio + pool. Split floorplan gives way to the owner ensuite- an oversized personal sanctuary - dressing rm w/ cherry built-ins + bath w/ soothing stone accents. Opposite is 3 graciously sized bdrms + 2 baths w/ calming stone + designer finishes.

1936 W Tanya Trail, Phoenix

$730,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6617869 MLS Non-Subdivision SubDv. CLOSED Status
Nestled on a sprawling 1.4-acre lot, this ranch-style residence offers a perfect blend of rustic charm & modern amenities. As you approach, you are greeted by beautifully crafted stonework fences that encircle the entire property, ensuring both privacy & security. The backyard is a true outdoor sanctuary, featuring a solar-heated fenced pool, inviting you to unwind in the warm embrace of the sun. The resort-style pool area is complemented by an array of amenities, including a built-in BBQ, perfect for entertaining guests on lazy Sunday afternoons. The meticulously landscaped garden also boasts horse stalls, a tack shed, & space for your equine companions. For the hobbyist, a finished air-conditioned work shed beckons. The interior of this home exudes warmth and sophistication. A charming wood fireplace graces the living area, creating a cozy ambiance during cooler evenings. Throughout the home, you'll find elegant plantation shutters, allowing natural light to filter in while preserving your privacy. The living spaces are tastefully tiled, offering both beauty and practicality, while the bedrooms are carpeted, providing a plush and comfortable retreat. Gourmet Kitchen and Dining The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, boasting granite counters and a convenient breakfast bar. Adjacent to the kitchen, a dining area features a bay window that overlooks the enchanting backyard, providing a scenic backdrop for every meal. Modern Comforts and Timeless Elegance This single-level abode offers not only modern comforts but also timeless elegance. With newer air conditioning ensuring your comfort, this residence is thoughtfully designed to provide the utmost in convenience and luxury. Each corner of this property reflects careful planning and an unwavering commitment to quality, inviting you to experience the true essence of ranch-style living against the backdrop of nature's grandeur. Serenity and Luxury Amidst Nature: Ranch-Style Haven with Majestic Mountain Views Nestled on a sprawling 1.4-acre lot, this picturesque ranch-style residence offers a haven of tranquility and sophistication. Breathtaking panoramic mountain views grace the horizon, setting the scene for a lifestyle of unmatched serenity and natural beauty. Outdoor Paradise Step into your private outdoor paradise, where a meticulously landscaped backyard awaits. A solar-heated fenced pool, adorned with a cascading waterfall feature, invites you to indulge in endless moments of relaxation. The entire backyard, enveloped by stonework fences and secured by an electric gate, ensures the utmost privacy and security. For the equestrian enthusiast, there are horse stalls, while a resort-style pool area and a built-in BBQ create the perfect ambiance for outdoor gatherings. Children can frolic on their wooden solid swing set with a slide, adding an element of joy and playfulness to the lush surroundings. Work and Leisure Spaces An air-conditioned and finished work shed beckons, providing an ideal space for creative pursuits or professional projects. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the two covered carports, offering protection for prized vehicles, along with the convenient 3-car garage featuring stained concrete floors, seamlessly attached to the main house.

38822 N 33rd Avenue, Phoenix

$620,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6611140 MLS Desert Hills SubDv. CLOSED Status
Over an acre of horse property adjacent to the Sonoran Mountain Preserve! Custom Home. Experience true privacy, natural beauty, and breathtaking views. Vaulted ceilings and bright open floorplan. Floors & baths updated in 2021 Split primary has separate updated tub/shower, 2 sinks, and separate exit to patio. Enjoy 360deg mountain vistas and sunsets, with no neighbors behind you! Room for horses, toys or elaborate gardens. Hike or Ride out onto 9,600 acres of public lands. Rear wall allows privacy and vehicle/pedestrian/equestrian access. Cozy up to your wood fireplace after long days exploring. Never feel cramped by city life again but have access to all the city's amenities just around the corner. RV electric and water Hookup. RV Shade cover.

37408 N 19th Avenue, Phoenix

$925,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6608492 MLS Ahwatukee Custom Estates SubDv. CLOSED Status
Take a look at this rare find! Nestled in the serene enclave of Equestrian Estates, discover a 3-bed, 2-bath residence that flawlessly combines upscale luxury w/ a touch of rustic charm. A meticulously curated landscape frames the home & invites guests through a welcoming front patio. Venture inside reveals an expansive open layout graced by vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, timeless plantation shutters, rich wood flooring, and a cozy fireplace. Entertain in style with a wet bar within reach, An adjoining formal dining room ensures festive dinners. At the same time, the kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's dream, showcasing tile counters, modern track lighting, recess panel cabinets, a quaint breakfast nook, and folding Nanno window . Outdoor fireplace, putting green, pool and spa.True Gem! A versatile center island doubles as a preparation area, while a delightful garden window provides the perfect spot to serve guests al fresco on the patio. The main bedroom is a sanctuary of relaxation, offering direct backyard access, a romantic fireplace, and an elegant ensuite with dual sinks and a walk-in closet. Witness breathtaking sunsets in the backyard paradise, displaying a full-length covered patio that overlooks an immaculately manicured lawn. Golf enthusiasts will revel in the personal putting green. Elevate outdoor gatherings with a full-fledged kitchen, atmospheric fireplace, invigorating spa, and a shimmering pool framed by majestic mountain views. This gem will sell fast!

3827 E Sequoia Trail, Phoenix

$852,500
3 Beds 3 Baths 6607361 MLS Sunburst Farms 14 SubDv. CLOSED Status
This is a Real Estate Auction for the Trust, not a foreclosure auction. We have a very transparent bidding process and are accepting your starting bids today! The ONLY preview/inspection dates are September 23 (Saturday) 9am-1PM & October 4 9am-1PM (Wednesday). Price listed is for MLS purposes only and this is the opening bid price for the home. It will sell to the highest bidder on October 7th, 2023 at 10AM sharp. You must be in person to bid on site that day. A 10% Buyers Premium on top of the final bid price will be added. Do not miss this opportunity to buy this house, it is selling at NO RESERVE with a opening bid of only $400,000. Additional amenities include a workshop w/attached cabinets, a chicken coop, horse facilities, & a convenient rear RV gate. Don't miss out!

15036 N 40th Lane, Phoenix

$694,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6606087 MLS Campobello SubDv. CLOSED Status
Unique Horse property located in the heart of north Phoenix. Remodeled 3 bed/2 bath w/ den on a large 36,940 sq ft lot, which can be subdivided for additional use. Beautiful gourmet kitchen w/ Merillat cabinets and many upgraded cabinet features. Beautiful master suite w/ large master closet and cozy fireplace. New roof 2022 w/ warranty, new A/C , newer dual pane windows throughout. Huge backyard offers a gorgeous paver area for your entertainment, spa hook up. 2 room storage barn w/ RV electrical hook up, large chicken coup penthouse, covered block horse stalls w/ electric/water, large round pen..... just too many upgrades to list here! Close to Desert Ridge w/ many shops & restaurants, quick access to the 101 & 51.

2906 E Danbury Road, Phoenix

$795,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 6603411 MLS Desert Hills SubDv. CLOSED Status
Pack your boxes and load the trailer! This stunning 4BR, 2BA home on a 1.4+ acres in N PHX offers breathtaking MTN views from every angle. It's the perfect blend of proximity to the city and the tranquility of the desert.The home features 2 HUGE double-size bedrooms, providing ample space for sleeping as well as a separate area for relaxation, entertainment, or a desk area for school or work. This layout is ideal for families with children of all ages or visitors who appreciate extra space. 1 of the bedrooms has a private entrance, perfect for a home business/office/gym. The backyard is a perfect setting for outdoor entertaining and relaxation. Come see this horse lover's dream, as it comes with 4 covered stalls w/ water & power, tack shed,hay barn, well-lit arena w/ 40G steel fencing

1741 W Tamar Road, Phoenix

$475,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6600424 MLS S35 T4n R3e SubDv. CLOSED Status
This charming 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is situated on a more than half acre lot, one of the largest lots in the community! Upon arriving at the property, you will be greeted by the spacious front yard featuring a large mature tree providing shade for sunny days. Explore inside to find a perfectly flowing layout. The recently updated kitchen features ample cabinet space, stylish backsplash, windows allowing for natural light, and stainless-steel appliances. From the dining area, you can pass through French doors into the oversized backyard with endless opportunities for entertaining just waiting for your personal touches. TONS of space for all your toys. The primary bedroom features a second entrance into your outdoor space with sliding glass doors leading to an attached patio. Home features a new roof, replaced just two years ago. No HOA!

17441 N 27th Street, Phoenix

$485,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 6597505 MLS N/A SubDv. CLOSED Status
Fall in love with this adorable single-level custom built, horse property with an RV gate and private pool! Home features wood-look & tile flooring, vaulted ceilings, and ceiling fans. Living room offering a cozy fireplace to keep you warm in the cooler months. The large eat-in kitchen is a cook's delight, displaying track lighting, honey oak cabinetry, built-in appliances, and sliding glass doors leading to the back patio and outside oasis. The primary bedroom comprised of a private bathroom and a walk-in closet. The serene backyard boasts a covered patio, storage shed, barn, and sparkling pool that is excellent for year-round enjoyment. This property is the perfect mix of convenience & functionality! LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! WELCOME HOME!!

3039 E Rosemonte Drive, Phoenix

$1,500,000
6 Beds 7 Baths 6564613 MLS Ahwatukee Custom Estates SubDv. CLOSED Status
Gorgeous 6 bed (plus den) / 6.5 bath two-story home w/ basement in an oversized cul-de-sac in the sought-after, upscale community of Ahwatukee Custom Estates. This home has been well-maintained with w/ the same owners for 24 years! Roof replacement in 2022 will allow you to buy w/ confidence. Upgrades include surround sound in every room, jetted tub in the primary bathroom, a private bathroom for all 6 bedrooms, central vac & much more. Spacious living room w/ soaring coffered ceiling & large picture window greets you. Den/Office conveniently located at front of home & has plantation shutters & built in desk w/ full wall of bookcases. Fantastic kitchen has subzero fridge, two dishwashers, double wall ovens, ice maker, two sinks (one in island) & peninsula w/ raised bar top perfect for additional seating or for serving when entertaining. Tons of cabinet storage, as well as a pantry. Kitchen opens to window lined dining area w/ door to back patio & the family room w/ vaulted ceilings, corner fireplace & French doors to back. Primary bedroom has beautiful tile fireplace as focal point, as well as built in wall unit & French doors to back. The primary bathroom offers two walk-in closets w/ organization, two separate vanities, luxurious spa tub, walk-in glass block snail shower & private toilet. All bedrooms have their own private bathroom for the win! And don't miss the amazing balcony views. Inside laundry room offers tons of cabinet storage, folding counter & deep utility sink. This home has tons of storage, including a massive storage closet w/ ceiling to floor shelving in basement & even more attic storage. Resort-like backyard offers mountain views along w/ the sprawling covered patio, bult-in BBQ station, sparkling diving pool w/ basketball hoop, spa, huge side yard w/ RV gate & basketball area, as well as lush green grassy area & perfectly placed landscaping including several large shade trees. Clean, 4 car garage w/ epoxy flooring & full wall of storage cabinets, as well as work bench w/ peg board. Located in the award winning Kyrene & Tempe school districts w/ easy access to the I-10. Just 15 minutes to Sky Harbor & less than 20 minutes to ASU & downtown Phoenix. Tons of shopping, dining & entertainment choices at your fingertips, as well as hiking/biking paths nearby on South Mountain just waiting to be explored. Be sure to check out this one-of-a-kind property today!

3521 E Hialea Court, Phoenix

Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.